If Mayweather never retired, would he or Pacquiao be p4p #1?

[Motofan]

you have to lose to lose you ranking..seeing that i dont believe mayweather would have lost..mayweather would still be #1

Not even slightly true. Had Mayweather stuck around and beat a couple no names, then Pac would be ranked #1. You have to keep your place, not just "not lose."

[Flawless.]

If he didn't fight anyone and Pacman beat Oscar he would drop to second.

[MakeDamnSure]

Floyd's best wins are from boring DECISIONS.

[JAB5239]

right. I said if he fought only once and that being miguel cotto and he won a tough but comfortable decision.

If that were the case Floyd would still be #1, but Manny would be nipping at his heels with a loud cry from his own fans to screaming for Pac to overtake Floyd.

Now.....lets say Floyd never retired yet fights Oscar and wins again, and Manny just has the two wins over Marquez and Diaz. Does Floyd retain that #1 spot? or does Manny take over?

[Flawless.]

If that were the case Floyd would still be #1, but Manny would be nipping at his heels with a loud cry from his own fans to screaming for Pac to overtake Floyd.

Now.....lets say Floyd never retired yet fights Oscar and wins again, and Manny just has the two wins over Marquez and Diaz. Does Floyd retain that #1 spot? or does Manny take over?

Manny Pacman would be number one

[larryx]

Not even slightly true. Had Mayweather stuck around and beat a couple no names, then Pac would be ranked #1. You have to keep your place, not just "not lose."

floyds a world class fighter when was the last time he fought a no name????

[aether]

pac ko delahoya > pbf UD12 cotto. pac #1

[Flawless.]

pac ko delahoya > pbf UD12 cotto. pac #1

Interesting

[aether]

Interesting

at the very best, they would be tied at #1. come on man. 2 belts 3 weight divisions in one year. that's pretty sick