Dave Tiberi vs. James Toney: the worst robbery?

[KostyaTszyu44]

Toney won the Jirov fight by razor thin decision imo.

-------------------------

And its ****** to say arm punchs as in bicep area, shoulder, kidney shots arn't scoring points. Forearm blocking thats gets a pass but depending if those forearms start hitting his face or his gloves start hitting his face and who's trying to make the fight.

Did Toney beat G.Johnson before or after Hopkins did?

they arent scoring points you idiot, target area is the front of the body and the head......arms and **** dont count, they can wear a fighter down and create opportunites later in the fight, but they dont score points

[SickmyDuck]

why the **** would he duck eubank or benn when he fought guys like RJJ mccallum jirov peter rahman nunn barkley etc


more like they didnt want him, toney would school those two guys on the same night if he had too, and you know it

just like he schooled Dave Tiberi

[TheManchine]

the people that scored that fight for Tiberi must have scored Castillo-Mayweather I for Castillo

you're not supposed to count punches that land on the arms, back and kidneys

head shots and body shots, that's it

just so you guys know how to score future fights

your forgetting that toney got ripped off twice vs montell griffin

the thing is though toneys defence is very good and sometimes when he is on the ropes covering he isnt actually getting hit with scoring shots but on the arms and with grazing shots, so it sometimes seems like he is getting the worst of it when he is actually not getting hit at all and tagging his opponent with counters

the tiberi decision wasnt all that bad, he wasnt landing cleanly only on the arms and that

James Toney WON the Tiberi fight. Tiberi was throwing hundreds of punches a round boucning off of Toney's arms and shoulders, and an out of shape Toney laid on the ropes and countered CLEANLY.... I had Toney winning the fight.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=237802

I lost that fight with Tiberi

Toney Fanboys

Even Toney admits he lost the fight

[Silencers]

Tiberi-Toney was a horrible decision, Tiberi won that fight comfortably.

[Lights0ut]

Toney Fanboys

Even Toney admits he lost the fight

And for the 17 years before where he said he won the fight, what did that mean to you? You can't use Toney's statements you dumb mother ****er since you never paid attention to them before.

James is a a guy who wants to KO his oppoenets and is never satisified unless he puts the lights out. He knows he was sloppy in that fight, so Im not surprised he now said he lost. He has high standards for himself.

Anyone who knows how to score a fight knows James won the fight. Clean punching wins fight, not 100's of arm punches that don't land.

[The Hammer]

Even Toney himself now admits Tiberi won.