Trinidad & Calzaghe "Who Ranks Higher All-Time" ?

[SonOfCuba]

If they both retired today (trinidad is most likely retired already) and Calzaghe keeps talking retirement, so if they both retired today... who ranks highers in the All-Time list.

Calzaghe has an undefeated record with wins against

Hopkins (43)
Jones (39 and really shot, face it)
Kessler
Eubank

Trinidad spent a few years known as the best in the game, one of the most respected knockout guys in recent times and with wins against

De La Hoya (Undefeated at the time)
Vargas (Undefeated at the time)
Mayorga
Whittiker

[badboypeenoy]

Trinidad

[sparked_85]

Calzaghe.

Calzaghe is unbeaten and reigned for over a decade. People will always make arguments for him being able to beat this or that guy because he never lost. Unlike Trinidad who to be fair his loses were mainly due to being out of his comfort zone weight class wise.

[dans]

Trinidad, no question. Being undefeated is overrated. If it meant as much as Calzaghe fans think it does, Rocky Marciano would be the greatest of all time.

Trinidad instilled fear in other fighters, unlike Calzaghe, and fought the best of the best. Clearly his downfall was going above 154, but either way I'll remember him as the better of the two.

[bishop2006]

Im amazed Calzaghes winning the poll,IMO,Trinidad is ranked way higher then Calzaghe

[dans]

Im amazed Calzaghes winning the poll,IMO,Trinidad is ranked way higher then Calzaghe

All the Calzaghe fans are just voting without defending themselves. Figures.

[badboypeenoy]

Chris John also has an unbeaten record, 10 title defenses spanning 4 years and has wins over Gainer and Marquez, I don't think he's even in the top ten P4P, much less a shoo-in for hall-of-fame.

[Porter's Dad]

Calzaghe.

Calzaghe is unbeaten and reigned for over a decade. People will always make arguments for him being able to beat this or that guy because he never lost. Unlike Trinidad who to be fair his loses were mainly due to being out of his comfort zone weight class wise.

Right...so Calzaghe is better by virtue of being lucky enough to having fought the 43 year version of Hopkins as opposed to the 36 year old version.

Unbeaten records don't mean **** in my eyes. How many times did SRR lose? Or Duran?

Hatton might have remained unbeaten if he hadn't had fought the best fighter of his generation.

[Tony628]

Im amazed Calzaghes winning the poll,IMO,Trinidad is ranked way higher then Calzaghe

thats your opinion but most logical and unbiased people would rank calzaghe higher.

[badboypeenoy]

thats your opinion but most logical and unbiased people would rank calzaghe higher.

Calzaghe fans? LMAO!!!!