Who is Higher All Time Great? Pac or Floyd

[MakeDamnSure]

not close, clearly mayweather.

It;s indeed not close.. Pac leads him by a million miles

[nujabes77]

not close, clearly mayweather.

you must be black.... jk hahahahha

[| THE KING |]

you must be black.... jk hahahahha

ohhh.. it starts !

[FasTHarD]

Pacman by a mile.. Most people here discredit Pac for beating Oscar....

[tito yuca]

Would Floyd lose to Morales and draw (and in most people's opinion LOSE) against Juan Manuel Marquez? I don't think so. Floyd has never lost, and damn near all his victories have been blowouts. He is much more skilled than Pacquiao and has the better resume and legacy BY FAR.

[KILLA RIGHT]

If may was humble may would have more votes.But these ppl are idiots and vote for manny lets vote about what happens in the ring guys

[Benny Leonard]

Would Floyd lose to Morales and draw (and in most people's opinion LOSE) against Juan Manuel Marquez? I don't think so. Floyd has never lost, and damn near all his victories have been blowouts. He is much more skilled than Pacquiao and has the better resume and legacy BY FAR.

No; I too brought that up. If Floyd faced who Pac fought; he would still have the "O"

Plus, if we look over careers and if people still want to bring up where Pac started we have to bring in the two KO losses.


I wonder if people think Pac would beat a Prime Diego Corrales. It might be possible because of Pac's speed.


I think Prime vs. Prime; Floyd is the better fighter. I don't think Pac could have beaten Floyd at Lightweight.

However, given Floyd's crap that comes out of his mouth and his deciding not to fight the best at 147 even though he claimed he was the best, to me, that hurts his legacy. So, I would put Pac just above him even though Pac bitched out of the 147 division too, but the big difference was that Pac never claimed he was the best at 147. He made his intention clear: O$car. True, that is why Floyd kept moving up, to get to Oscar, but, unlike Pac, Floyd boasted how he was the best there.

[nujabes77]

No; I too brought that up. If Floyd faced who Pac fought; he would still have the "O"
Plus, if we look over careers and if people still want to bring up where Pac started we have to bring in the two KO losses.


I wonder if people think Pac would beat a Prime Diego Corrales. It might be possible because of Pac's speed.

if pac faced who floyd fought... you shouldn't belittle pacman's opposition

[Benny Leonard]

Pacman by a mile.. Most people here discredit Pac for beating Oscar....

Freddie did already. He is the one that mentioned Oscar couldn't pull the trigger and mentioned before and especially after about the weight of Oscar ruined him, just like it did many others.

Have a talk with Freddie.

You don't get credit for beating a corpse.

It's the same with Holmes and Ali.

[BennyST]

Far out, they haven't even finished their careers. Pac still has years left while it is unsure whether FM will come back but he probably will. These type of threads always happen too early.

Anyway, as an ATG, I would say right now that Mayweather is a bit ahead (as in if they both stopped fighting right now).