Is Floyd Mayweather jr an ATG?

[AKATheMack]

So if you know what he has accomplished at 130-135...this why would you question him as an ATG?

Because I feel he should have stayed and continued to fight other great fighters instead of jumping up in weight to claim meaningless belts against fighter like Baldomir.

[wmute]

I felt the need to specify I feel most of you are ***** made and ARENT real men just ****riders.

I see I see ... you like ****, but you are ashamed to admit it, hence all the real man talk

As tolerant as I am, I will admit that I would be ashamed too if I were you.

So back to the beating a top notch pro boxer in a street fight, what are you trained in again?

[wmute]

Because I feel he should have stayed and continued to fight other great fighters instead of jumping up in weight to claim meaningless belts against fighter like Baldomir.

Baldomir was the Ring and lineal champ at 147. How is that belt meaningless?

[El Dominicano]

Because I feel he should have stayed and continued to fight other great fighters instead of jumping up in weight to claim meaningless belts against fighter like Baldomir.

His GREAT status came at 130-135 and I'm 100% sure you don't fully understand what he did there...to even question his GREATNESS.

[AKATheMack]

I am confused, wasnt the other the reply to my post?

HE BEAT THE BEST AT 140. DID YOU MISS THAT?

EDIT: Why did you mention Hopkins again?

DeMarcus Corley Brussels(sp?) and Gatti were his only 140lb fights he did not fight the best at 140 but Im the one who started watching boxing this morning?

[wmute]

DeMarcus Corley Brussels(sp?) and Gatti were his only 140lb fights he did not fight the best at 140 but Im the one who started watching boxing this morning?

Who has been the lineal 140 champ for the past 3 years?

He has ONE loss. to whom?

[Sweet Pea 50]

I have no problem with people putting him in the top 25. And now, I will run from this thread like a man with his **** set on fire......

[AKATheMack]

His GREAT status came at 130-135 and I'm 100% sure you don't fully understand what he did there...to even question his GREATNESS.

two wins over JLC is great but doesnt promote you to an ATG at 135. Im looking at an ATG career and at 130 4 fights before he jumped he was fighting a fighter who was 22-16 despite how good a 22-16 fighter he was he wasnt a great fighter.

[AKATheMack]

Who has been the lineal 140 champ for the past 3 years?

He has ONE loss. to whom?

He didnt beat him at 140 so thats irrelevant he wasnt the best 147lber in the world so why fight him at 147? Hatton had a hell of a time with Collazo at 147 so that win proves almost **** to me.

[wmute]

two wins over JLC is great but doesnt promote you to an ATG at 135. Im looking at an ATG career and at 130 4 fights before he jumped he was fighting a fighter who was 22-16 despite how good a 22-16 fighter he was he wasnt a great fighter.

who should he have fought at 135?