Who defends Marg's decision to fight Mosley instead of Williams?

[Eric Holder]

if Tony never fights PWill I'll be dissapointed but I think by the end of '09 there's gonna be a reamatch


plus it's not like Shane's a scrub, he's still a top 4 welter weight and a great name to add to a resume

[Mr. Fantastic]

An old shot future HOF. You can't be serious if you think more credit should be given if he'd beat SSM rather then the man that beat him.

But its ok for PW to fight Verno then?? A 39 year old guy who isn't a HOF.

I want to see PW vs Marg 2, but Williams declined it and NOW calling out Margs. He should of taken the rematch when he had the chance. Not Margs fault.

[SalvaDominicano]

An old shot future HOF. You can't be serious if you think more credit should be given if he'd beat SSM rather then the man that beat him.

No, more credit is due for beating Williams. I agree. Adding more to his legacy = beating Mosley. Two different things.

[HendrixLove]

Man you guy's are pathetic. None of you know what the **** happens business wise. The only thing you guy's see with your own eyes is the actual fight. None of you see what happens behind closed doors so shut the fu#k up with the fu#cken business talk.

[El Dominicano]

But its ok for PW to fight Verno then?? A 39 year old guy who isn't a HOF.

I want to see PW vs Marg 2, but Williams declined it and NOW calling out Margs. He should of taken the rematch when he had the chance. Not Margs fault.

See NOTICE I didn't say it was. Nothing wrong with gettin a belt at 154 when certain fighters don't want to fight you.

All I'm sayin is

A Paul Williams win would do alot more for Margarito then a SSM win

That is all.

[El Dominicano]

No, more credit is due for beating Williams. I agree. Adding more to his legacy = beating Mosley. Two different things.

Only a name. Where would DLH be ranked if he'd of beaten a prime Pernell/ JCC? People will always look into that

We can't act like SSM didn't look like **** against Mayorga

[SalvaDominicano]

See NOTICE I didn't say it was. Nothing wrong with gettin a belt at 154 when certain fighters don't want to fight you.

All I'm sayin is

A Paul Williams win would do alot more for Margarito then a SSM win

That is all.

It really wouldn't. SSM is already a future HOF whereas Williams is nowhere near there yet. He has yet to prove himself against top quality opposition whether if they are willing to fight him or not. A SSM win does alot more than a PW win.

[SalvaDominicano]

Only a name. Where would DLH be ranked if he'd of beaten a prime Pernell/ JCC? People will always look into that

We can't act like SSM didn't look like **** against Mayorga

That's exactly my point. He didn't beat a prime Whitaker but when people speak of DLH's most memorable fights, who do they mention most of the time???? You guessed it.

[El Dominicano]

That's exactly my point. He didn't beat a prime Whitaker but when people speak of DLH's most memorable fights, who do they mention most of the time???? You guessed it.

I'll make a poll. I'll admit this could be debated

We'll just have to agree to disagree

[SalvaDominicano]

Only a name. Where would DLH be ranked if he'd of beaten a prime Pernell/ JCC? People will always look into that

We can't act like SSM didn't look like **** against Mayorga

I'll make a poll. I'll admit this could be debated

We'll just have to agree to disagree

Agreed. At least we talked about this like normal human beings. or could it be that we're both reasonable Dominicans? lol