Who beat the better Hopkins: Jones or Calzaghe?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Dirk is a very simple man. He's like "Simple Jack". He doesn't understand that when you are kicking someone's ass who is not fighting back, you can pretty much do whatever you want no matter what your stamina is.

Yawn.

No you're the simpleton. I knew the answer, I wanted the ****** answer.

Everyone knows Calzaghe is superior to Pavlik hence why he beat Hopkins and Pavlik got dominated.

[Benny Leonard]

Joe is no spring chicken either
its not Joe's fault they all ducked him in their prime

So was it Roy's fault Joe didn't move up in weight and come to America?

If you are an actor and want to make big budget movies...where do you go?

[Benny Leonard]

RJJ beat a green Hopkins

Hopkins was an experienced defensive master and one of the best p4p fighters in the world when Calzaghe beat him.

Calzaghe beat the better Hopkins

He was so green he had one more fight that Roy Jones Jr.

He was so green he was able to challenge for the title.

He was so green he was Prison Champion in boxing.

He was so green he never faced Roy again.

The only thing Green about Hopkins was the color of his **** that night.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

So was it Roy's fault Joe didn't move up in weight and come to America?

If you are an actor and want to make big budget movies...where do you go?

Man you keep spouting this **** about everyone. Like moving up in weight and coming to America is suddenly gonna get Jones to step in the ring with him. Its not that easy. Whats he supposed to do? Fight the same bums on undercards in America? Yeah Jones is really gonna take notice then.

Nigel Benn came to America and knocked out a bunch of Yanks but never got closer to fighting Jones. Steve Collins fought most of his career in America and relentlessly called out Jones.

[theghost#1]

[QUOTE=P4P Opinion;4387234]I think we can all agree that neither version of Hopkins can be considered the prime version, but which is the more impressive victory? I'm not talking about the method of victory by the way and nor am I interested if you think Hopkins beat Calzaghe. Calzaghe beat Hopkins, that is a fact.* Who beat the better Hopkins?





The B-Hop that lost to Roy was too green and still a no name. The B- Hop that lost to Calzaghe fought and beat Tarver, WW, Pavlik. no comparison.

[Jumpman23]

[QUOTE=theghost#1;4390105]

I think we can all agree that neither version of Hopkins can be considered the prime version, but which is the more impressive victory? I'm not talking about the method of victory by the way and nor am I interested if you think Hopkins beat Calzaghe. Calzaghe beat Hopkins, that is a fact.* Who beat the better Hopkins?





The B-Hop that lost to Roy was too green and still a no name. The B- Hop that lost to Calzaghe fought and beat Tarver, WW, Pavlik. no comparison.

yea, but he lost to JT not once but twice...