Who Wins the Fight...Margarito or Floyd?

[El Dominicano]

Maybe so, but Cotto is the latest and surely the most famous example of Margarito's granite chin. It's pretty simple math to me. If Cotto can't hurt Margarito, then Mayweather can't either.

Yes Pernell couldn't hurt JCC
JCC>>>Margarito

[Wiley Hyena]

Any fighter moving up from 140 to fight Margarito should be jailed for attempted suicide.

Idk, I just find it harder to believe what you say than most because of how highly you ranked Hatton, and now give Floyd nearly 0 credit for the win.

I don't even really care, I don't think the fight will ever happen, and I want Floyd to stay retired if that is the case.

I give Mayweather alot of credit for the win over Hatton. But, clearly...Hatton is not Margarito. He just isn't. He isn't Cotto, either.

You can ask yourself a question: Does Mayweather's legacy rest with domination of the WWs, or just the lower weight divisions? This really is the question of the hour. I believe that most would think that Floyd cannot secure his own self stated legacy without domination of the welter weight division. This is where I'm coming from.

[El Dominicano]

Wiley unless you have Margarito and Cotto p4p #1 and #2 in the sport
it doesnt Matter....

because I exposed you for what you are...and that is an avid hater...

If you cant give Floyd credit for Knocking out a Fighter who you thought was the 3rd Greatest Fighter in all of Boxing who was undefeated and in His Prime....


You will never Hive him Credit for anything, and always make excuses if he beats the guys you think he couldnt beat...

Horus don't waste your time with him. It ain't worth it

[Fox McCloud]

I give Mayweather alot of credit for the win over Hatton. But, clearly...Hatton is not Margarito. He just isn't. He isn't Cotto, either.

You can ask yourself a question: Does Mayweather's legacy rest with domination of the WWs, or just the lower weight divisions? This really is the question of the hour. I believe that most would think that Floyd cannot secure his own self stated legacy without domination of the welter weight division. This is where I'm coming from.

He cannot really add the WW division to his legacy.

But it's not like his legacy suffers IMO...

It just does not get the added benefits that it would if he did clean out 147.

He really isn't a WW IMO... but he also should not have gotten into the division if he didn't want to deal with people calling for him to fight the best in the division.

[Wiley Hyena]

Wiley unless you have Margarito and Cotto p4p #1 and #2 in the sport
it doesnt Matter....

because I exposed you for what you are...and that is an avid hater...

If you cant give Floyd credit for Knocking out a Fighter who you thought was the 3rd Greatest Fighter in all of Boxing who was undefeated and in His Prime....


You will never give him Credit for anything, and always make excuses if he beats the guys you think he couldnt beat...

THIS makes no sense. So I believe Pacquiao is #1 p4p. Does this mean Pac beats Cotto or Margarito or Calzaghe or Hopkins, etc.....??

Give it a break man. I missed the call on Hatton-Mayweather. I missed it. If I could predict them all, I would be a millionaire.

[12boxin_C12]

Floyd WIDE decision in a fight that Floyd lands and lands and lands some more.

more like floyd pedals and pedals and pedals on his bicycle to lose either a UD or by TKO jus cause margarito is too strong n relentless. simple.

[El Dominicano]

more like floyd pedals and pedals and pedals on his bicycle to lose either a UD or by TKO jus cause margarito is too strong n relentless. simple.

Leme get this straight

How would Margarito be relentless if Floyd so called "Pedals Pedals"

[Horus]

Horus don't waste your time with him. It ain't worth it

Man, "Dominicano" It is not just him, it is all these posters who think like him.
Remember when Floyd fought Baldomir, you had people saying

Baldomir:
"AWW floyd is fighting a real WW now, he cant pot shot against Baldomir, because he will get
KTFO, BECAUSE bALDOMIR is not Zab Judah he is a Real WW champion"

What Happen?

Oscar De La Hoya:
"AWW floyd is too small for Oscar, he has never fought a fighter like DLH,
he has been fighting bums, and Oscar is the best guy he has ever fought, and Oscar is too big for Mayweather, and he is going to knock Mayweather the FUC* OUT"

What Happen?

Ricky Hatton:
"Aww Floyd cant run against Hatton, Hatton is going to take aways Floyds body and make Floyd fight, FLOYD CANT TAKE THE PRESSURE...this aint Oscar
Hatton is going to KNOCK Mayweather the FUC* OUT"

What Happen?

See the Problem is these fighters always think the next fighter is always the guy who is going to beat Mayweather and Knock him the FUC* OUT
and when Mayweather beats the guy who they thought he couldnt beat...
There is always an excuse...


and I just proved it right now with Wiley...

[Wiley Hyena]

He cannot really add the WW division to his legacy.

But it's not like his legacy suffers IMO...

It just does not get the added benefits that it would if he did clean out 147.

He really isn't a WW IMO... but he also should not have gotten into the division if he didn't want to deal with people calling for him to fight the best in the division.

If Floyd is going to say he is the best in the division, then he must prove it or his legacy suffers. That's pretty simple. At 130-135, Floyd was one of the best I've ever seen. There's his credit. At 140 and up, there's lingering questions, IMO. It depends on where he wanted to take it. He took it way up there. Hard to live up to that.

[Fox McCloud]

If Floyd is going to say he is the best in the division, then he must prove it or his legacy suffers. That's pretty simple. At 130-135, Floyd was one of the best I've ever seen. There's his credit. At 140 and up, there's lingering questions, IMO. It depends on where he wanted to take it. He took it way up there. Hard to live up to that.

Agreed...

His legacy is solidified as a super featherweight and a lightweight, and there will be a what if question in both junior welterweight and welterweight.