Who Wins the Fight...Margarito or Floyd?

[Horus]

THIS makes no sense. So I believe Pacquiao is #1 p4p. Does this mean Pac beats Cotto or Margarito or Calzaghe or Hopkins, etc.....??

Give it a break man. I missed the call on Hatton-Mayweather. I missed it. If I could predict them all, I would be a millionaire.

You make no sense, my point is Unless you have Margarito or Cotto rated Higher than you had Hatton ranked..p4p...

then it doesnt matter because you had Hatton has the 3rd GREATEST fighter in all of boxing... Above Margarito and Cotto...
(Nobody told you to do this either you did it on your own)

before Hatton Fought Mayweather....

Meaning you thought Hatton would be a bigger win than Margarito or Cotto status wise...because you thought he was the 3rd Greatest fighter in the sport.

And When Mayweather Beat him and Knock him out....
You still discredited the win...

[Wiley Hyena]

Yes Pernell couldn't hurt JCC
JCC>>>Margarito

JCC may be greater than Margarito, but that doesn't mean anything to Mayweather. No way Floyd can hold up to Margarito. He'll have to run. Let's just put it this way, if Mayweather can stand in with Margarito and win......then he's automatically ATG, period. IMO. The problem is that it won't happen.

[Wiley Hyena]

You make no sense, my point is Unless you have Margarito or Cotto rated Higher than you had Hatton ranked..p4p...

then it doesnt matter because you had Hatton has the 3rd GREATEST fighter in all of boxing... Above Margarito and Cotto...
(Nobody told you to do this either you did it on your own)

before Hatton Fought Mayweather....

Meaning you thought Hatton would be a bigger win than Margarito or Cotto status wise...because you thought he was the 3rd Greatest fighter in the sport.

And When Mayweather Beat him and Knock him out....
You still discredited the win...

You make no sense. I always had Pacquiao #1 p4p. This doesn't mean he can beat Hopkins. You're missing the point. Margarito too big and strong for Floyd. p4p is irrelevant.

[Fox McCloud]

JCC may be greater than Margarito, but that doesn't mean anything to Mayweather. No way Floyd can hold up to Margarito. He'll have to run. Let's just put it this way, if Mayweather can stand in with Margarito and win......then he's automatically ATG, period. IMO. The problem is that it won't happen.

That's dumb to put a stipulation on how he has to win.

If he wins by a large margin "running", then he should get a lot of credit.

If he stands in and wins, then he is an idiot for making it hard on himself.

We'll call him Meldrick Taylor the 2nd.

[Wiley Hyena]

That's dumb to put a stipulation on how he has to win.

If he wins by a large margin "running", then he should get a lot of credit.

If he stands in and wins, then he is an idiot for making it hard on himself.

We'll call him Meldrick Taylor the 2nd.

I'm not stipulating anything. If Floyd beats Margarito, it's a great win. Standing in with Margarito, is a greater win, but this won't happen for obvious reasons.

I'm going to bed now. Good night crew.

[Fox McCloud]

I'm not stipulating anything. If Floyd beats Margarito, it's a great win. Standing in with Margarito, is a greater win, but this won't happen for obvious reasons.

I'm going to bed now. Good night crew.

I just don't see why Floyd would get less credit for fighting his style than he would for not fighting his style against Margarito... that doesn't make sense.

That's like saying that Margarito gets more credit if he moves around the ring and outjabs Joshua Clottey in the rematch... it's silly.

Lol, why the **** am I spending so much time talking about a fight that will never happen?

[El Dominicano]

Man, "Dominicano" It is not just him, it is all these posters who think like him.
Remember when Floyd fought Baldomir, you had people saying

Baldomir:
"AWW floyd is fighting a real WW now, he cant pot shot against Baldomir, because he will get
KTFO, BECAUSE bALDOMIR is not Zab Judah he is a Real WW champion"

What Happen?

Oscar De La Hoya:
"AWW floyd is too small for Oscar, he has never fought a fighter like DLH,
he has been fighting bums, and Oscar is the best guy he has ever fought, and Oscar is too big for Mayweather, and he is going to knock Mayweather the FUC* OUT"

What Happen?

Ricky Hatton:
"Aww Floyd cant run against Hatton, Hatton is going to take aways Floyds body and make Floyd fight, FLOYD CANT TAKE THE PRESSURE...this aint Oscar
Hatton is going to KNOCK Mayweather the FUC* OUT"

What Happen?

See the Problem is these fighters always think the next fighter is always the guy who is going to beat Mayweather and Knock him the FUC* OUT
and when Mayweather beats the guy who they thought he couldnt beat...
There is always an excuse...


and I just proved it right now with Wiley...

Honestly, they know what we know...they just want to hate. I also remember alot of people picking Baldy, Hatton and DLH

[Easy-E]

Floyd makes easy work of the slow, plodding Margarito.

[Equilibrium]

Floyd makes Margarito look ****** for 12 rounds.

[Easy-E]

You make no sense. I always had Pacquiao #1 p4p. This doesn't mean he can beat Hopkins. You're missing the point. Margarito too big and strong for Floyd. p4p is irrelevant.

This is the most tired point of all regarding this matchup.
It is very representitive of your overall boxing knowledge.