James Toney: ATG Or Not?

[Truth]

discuss....

Achievements
• The WBA Heavyweight Champion 4/30/2005 Ruled no-decision
• The Ring Magazine “2003 Fighter of the Year”
• USA Today “2003 Fighter of the Year”
• World championship fights - 10-1-1
• Rated WBO #1, The Ring #5, WBC #3, WBA #3, IBF #4 at heavyweight
• Former IBF cruiserweight world champion
• Former IBF super middleweight world champion, 3 successful defenses
• Former IBF middleweight world champion, 6 successful defenses
• Former USBA light heavyweight champion
• The Ring Magazine “1991 Fighter of the Year”

https://www.Jamestoney.com

[Flab]

Most definitely!

[Stab Judah]

Deion Sanders

[Truth]

Its split 3-3 right now. I knew this would be a good poll. It will be interesting to see what opinion on here prevails.

[cace]

no doubt he is

[Truth]

I think skills wise its undeniable. Also Toney has one of the greatest chins ever.

[BKM-]

Yes he is. He has some great accomplishments and as a fighter he was extremely crafty and gifted. I think for most who do not believe he is ATG status haven't been able to witness "Lights Out" before he became a fatty failing at HW over and over again.

[ironalex]

Of Course He Is, Anyone Who Dont Think James Toney Is An Atg, Either Dont Kno **** About Boxing, Or A Hater.

[larryx]

hands down 80 fights..old school

[Jupiter Maximus]

HOF sure..

ATG....**** no

He never once unified...lost to Montell Grifith and Sam Peter twice...was a disgrace as a heavy...cheated numerous times

Im sorry those don't get you ATG status