Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[Frank Martin]

how could he possibly be, he's british hence not even a hall of famer.

Yeah Lennox Lewis is not a Hall of Famer.

[mathed]

Oh man, I don't even think his biggest nut huggers would do that. His momma wouldn't even do that. He might be in the top 30 greatest super middleweights from Wales of all time but that's about it.

Top 25 greatest smw period, but not p4p. Not a hugger but he ruled that division.

[Wiley Hyena]

Top 25 greatest smw period, but not p4p. Not a hugger but he ruled that division.

Better than that, I would say.

[hammerhiem]

Yeah, who the hell would put him in the Top 30 of all time? I can name 100 fighters better than him. Very good fighter, lots of things I like about him, but no way in the top 100.

I did a top 100 the other day purely to place his ass at 100 and to be honest once you get past 80 you start really reaching, he's probably top 80-90 All time which for me makes him not an ATG because after you get past 50 you start into people with large flaws in their reasons for being on the list.

[Wiley Hyena]

I did a top 100 the other day purely to place his ass at 100 and to be honest once you get past 80 you start really reaching, he's probably top 80-90 All time which for me makes him not an ATG because after you get past 50 you start into people with large flaws in their reasons for being on the list.

Could you post your top 50 for analysis? Don't mean to impose but it would be interesting to see.

[Benncollinsaad]

I'd call him the best "white" boxer, but that would offend you Wiley. He really is.

[SOPH~ REP.]

Not he is good and retired unbeaten .He needs a better resume 2 b n the discussion as G.O.A.T

[Wiley Hyena]

I'd call him the best "white" boxer, but that would offend you Wiley. He really is.

That doesn't offend me. It offends the Irish.

[Benncollinsaad]

That doesn't offend me. It offends the Irish.

How so? They are among the whitest people in the world!

[Wiley Hyena]

How so? They are among the whitest people in the world!

Only if you look at it from the air. From the internet there's no such thing.