Better Resume: Calzaghe or Mayweather?

[Pugilistic™]

Bottom line, which fighters does Mayweather have on his resume greater than Jones and Hopkins?

Oscar is the only one who comes close and even he isn't as great as those two, far from it.

To be fair Jones is way past it.

Hopkins is only slightly past his prime like Joe so the win is a good one even if the fight was close.

[hugh grant]

JC has a better record. JC is beating people in his mid thirties. Could PBF still be succesful at that age?

[Madvillain]

Mayweather, it's not even close. Calzaghe beat two fighters who already have a foot in the retirement home. Lacy is a nobody, and Kessler is still unproven. You can try and argue that Joe wanted the big fights but because he was in Wales, couldn't get them, but the fact is whether that's true or not, he doesn't have any recognizable names on his resume before Lacy. Mayweather has beaten more recognizable and credible names than Calzaghe has, and he's held more titles in more divisions than Joe has. In terms of resume? There's no contest here.

I personally think Joe is overrated and overhyped, but I admit he's got great skills. Still he's not better than Mayweather at anything. Except being white... and having a hot wife... and being from Europe...

[Ray*]

Hopkins fight was very close could have gone either way and Hopkins is 43
RJJ is shot, name his last good win

Thats why i said at this stage RJJ and B-hop are just names...

[cace]

i dont think its even close
floyd has by far the better resume

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

You picking the wrong names, Take out Bika and manfredo and replace that with Kessler,Reid and woodhall(2 big domestic fight), A prime Castillo and a prime Corley..

I dont Pick castillo because for me, castillo woooped Floyds ass in the first fight, so I dont count that as a win for Floyd. and I think Bika was better than woodhall.

[Flawless 2]

I dont Pick castillo because for me, castillo woooped Floyds ass in the first fight, so I dont count that as a win for Floyd. and I think Bika was better than woodhall.

Whooped, how many rounds did you think Castillo won by??

[sterling]

mayweather but calzaghe isnt far off plus mayweather has never beaten a prime undefeated fighter.

[Flawless 2]

mayweather but calzaghe isnt far off plus mayweather has never beaten a prime undefeated fighter.

Ricky Hatton
Diego Corrales
Jesus Chavez( did lose once but was his 5th fight)

[Pullcounter]

JC has a better record. JC is beating people in his mid thirties. Could PBF still be succesful at that age?

beating people in your mid thirties doesn't make your record better.