Better Resume: Calzaghe or Mayweather?

[Pullcounter]

discuss and give your opinion

floyd fought from 130 to 154 without losing.

let's see calz move up to CW then HW without losing... then we'll talk.

[Silencers]

Definitely Mayweather.

[Check]

Mayweather by a long shot. Mayweather haters knock him at welterweight. Floyd wasn't a true welter. Look at who he beat at featherweight and lightweight, those were the weights he was amazing at and the only guy in his prime at that weight you can even say he may of ducked is Kostya. I can think of many prime fighters at Joes natural weight he didnt get in the ring with. Not to mention all the different weights Mayweather won at. Not even close.

[Flawless 2]

Very close poll

[Ray*]

Mayweather but not by much. I give calzaghe credit for , Eubank,Bika,Manfredo, Lacy,Hopkins and Jones. And I give credit to Mayweather for,Hernandez, Corrales,Chavez,Judah, DLH and Hatton. They both have 6 credible opponents, but I think Floyds opponents where slightly better.

You picking the wrong names, Take out Bika and manfredo and replace that with Kessler,Reid and woodhall(2 big domestic fight), A prime Castillo and a prime Corley..

[RichCCFC]

Bottom line, which fighters does Mayweather have on his resume greater than Jones and Hopkins?

Oscar is the only one who comes close and even he isn't as great as those two, far from it.

[Ray*]

Bottom line, which fighters does Mayweather have on his resume greater than Jones and Hopkins?

Oscar is the only one who comes close and even he isn't as great as those two, far from it.

Well at this stage Hopkins and jones are names.

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

Mayweather by a long shot. Mayweather haters knock him at welterweight. Floyd wasn't a true welter. Look at who he beat at featherweight and lightweight, those were the weights he was amazing at and the only guy in his prime at that weight you can even say he may of ducked is Kostya. I can think of many prime fighters at Joes natural weight he didnt get in the ring with. Not to mention all the different weights Mayweather won at. Not even close.

im gonna have to defend floyd about ducking tszyu. it might have happened but tszyu lost his title to hatton, who had no interest in fighting floyd until 2007...and floyd busted that ass.

[Flawless 2]

Well at this stage Hopkins and jones are names.

Hopkins fight was very close could have gone either way and Hopkins is 43
RJJ is shot, name his last good win

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

rjj is way pasth is prime and anyone who saw his fights with tito and hanshaw would know that