VIC DARCHINYAN - P4P Top 10 ??

[MELLY-MEL...]

well they are kinda even since VIC made Nonito's brother an even bigger HO...

id rather get KOd then quit midway in a fight making lame excuses... Glen is an embarrasment to Nonito.

and this, wtf does nonitos win have to do with glen losing? kinda even? your a ****ing block head!

[Dan...]

well the question was pretty obvious...

Nonito was a NOBODY... is now a half-way somebody... and when he fights VIC again, he will be an even bigger NOBODY.

All that is irrelevant. The facts are these:

1) Vic put together a pretty decent run as Flyweight champ without beating any huge names
2) He was KTFO by Nonito Donaire last year - a fighter you say is pretty much a nobody
3) He has come back and become the man at superfly and knocked out a p4p fighter in very impressive fashion.

Whilst this last point significantly increases his reputation and standing in the sport it simply isn't enough to put him on the p4p list, no way. He needs to beat another top guy, a montiel or somebody, and then he should be seriously considered for the list. Remember you have guys like Ivan Calderon struggling to make that list. It isn't like a "one great win and then you are on it" type list.

[Chups]

That "Nobody" dominated and KTFO your boy.

Honestly I don't think Donaire needs to rematch Vic. Donaire can move to other things like fighting Arce, Montiel or those Japanese flyweight Champs. If Vic wants a rematch let his team beg for it. It's true Vic made Nonito more famous....but Nonito should use that and fly on his own.

[MELLY-MEL...]

All that is irrelevant. The facts are these:

1) Vic put together a pretty decent run as Flyweight champ without beating any huge names
2) He was KTFO by Nonito Donaire last year - a fighter you say is pretty much a nobody
3) He has come back and become the man at superfly and knocked out a p4p fighter in very impressive fashion.

Whilst this last point significantly increases his reputation and standing in the sport it simply isn't enough to put him on the p4p list, no way. He needs to beat another top guy, a montiel or somebody, and then he should be seriously considered for the list. Remember you have guys like Ivan Calderon struggling to make that list. It isn't like a "one great win and then you are on it" type list.

thats a nice post man!

[Pullcounter]

What you guys think??

Does Vic Darchinyan (31-1, 25KOs) deserve Top 10 P4P status after unifying 3titles at Super Flyweight? (WBC, WBA, IBF).

if you beat a p4p top 10 fighter u get on that list. he's not high on it but maybe around 9-10.

seriously, if a margarito can get on it vic can.

[Bonsi]

well they are kinda even since VIC made Nonito's brother an even bigger HO...

id rather get KOd then quit midway in a fight making lame excuses... Glen is an embarrasment to Nonito.

wrong, Vic is the bigger ho, because he was an ass before and after the brutal KO. he is up there with Zab Judah in the embarrasment ratings.

[ANDROID_DOES]

i wish we had this same thread before the Mijares fight... cuz i guarantee some guys would have said somethin similar...

"if he beats Mijares, there is no reason since Mijares is a long time WBC, WBA champ... unbeaten in 6 years, title holder for 4."


i guess theres always a reason huh...

a question ernie asked you in your other thread. Where did you put zahir raheem on your p4p list when he beat morales? If only one win got you in the p4p list the p4p list would consist of a hundred people. Tell me who on the p4p list should vic replace and why?

[Pullcounter]

It isn't like a "one great win and then you are on it" type list.

actually yeah, it is.

margarito got on it for beating cotto. cotto got on it for beating mosley. calzaghe got on it for beating lacy. hatton got on it for beating tszyu. etc...

[VanesBoxing]

Honestly I don't think Donaire needs to rematch Vic. Donaire can move to other things like fighting Arce, Montiel or those Japanese flyweight Champs. If Vic wants a rematch let his team beg for it. It's true Vic made Nonito more famous....but Nonito should use that and fly on his own.

of course he needs to rematch VIC

just like VIC should maybe rematch Mijares... IFF.. a BIG IF.. Mijares asks for it.

in big fights like that with so much on the line, once the underdog wins, it is fair to offer a rematch in respect to a long standing champion... IF that champion really wants it.

In the Mijares case, I doubt Mijares will want anything to do with VIC again...

but VIC has clearly shown in many occasions that he is ready for Donaire at any time.

[VanesBoxing]

actually yeah, it is.

margarito got on it for beating cotto. cotto got on it for beating mosley. calzaghe got on it for beating lacy. hatton got on it for beating tszyu. etc...

there you go man..