VIC DARCHINYAN - P4P Top 10 ??

[VanesBoxing]

What you guys think??

Does Vic Darchinyan (31-1, 25KOs) deserve Top 10 P4P status after unifying 3titles at Super Flyweight? (WBC, WBA, IBF).

[PoetryInMotion]

No...............

[VanesBoxing]

No...............

why not??

wasn't Mijares one of your heroes??? or are you still bitter about the beating?

[Addition]

Nah, maybe top 15 though.

[Xyei]

Not yet IMO. If he lands the fight with Vazquez and defeats him, then he might be a candidate.

[kenso]

Not yet IMO. If he lands the fight with Vazquez and defeats him, then he might be a candidate.

if he beats vasquez theres no ****ing reason why he shouldnt be.

[Ryn0]

Not until he defeats Donaire, a P4P top 10 fighter can't have been KTFO and being beating on the points without avenging that loss.

[VanesBoxing]

if he beats vasquez theres no ****ing reason why he shouldnt be.

i wish we had this same thread before the Mijares fight... cuz i guarantee some guys would have said somethin similar...

"if he beats Mijares, there is no reason since Mijares is a long time WBC, WBA champ... unbeaten in 6 years, title holder for 4."


i guess theres always a reason huh...

[ippo]

Id put him the top 10 if he beats doniare or montiel.

[Xyei]

if he beats vasquez theres no ****ing reason why he shouldnt be.

I agree with that. My original post wasn't worded right.