Rate these fighters in order of greatness (Jones, Calzaghe, Hopkins, Toney, & MORE!!)

[1SILVA]

Rate These Fighters In Order

1. Roy Jones
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. James Toney
4. Joe Calzaghe
5. Gerald Mclellan
6. Chris Eubank
7. Dariusz
8. Antonio Tarver
9. Nigel Benn
10. Ottke
11. Steve Collins

[Fulcrum29]

1. Bernard Hopkins
2. Roy Jones
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. James Toney (I consider Toney probably more skilled than Calzaghe but due to his life long problems + laziness he gets some points off for inconsistence, like his mid career losses to guys like Griffin that if he were prepared he would have destroyed them)
5. Darius Michelczewski
6. Chris Eubank
7. Nigel Benn
8. Sven Ottke
9. Steve Collins
10. Gerald Mclellan

[DiegoFuego]

I would go

1. Hopkins
2. Jones - sorry, Roy, you've been ousted in the last 3 years big time
3. Toney
4. Calzaghe
5. Tarver
6. Eubank
7. Benn
8. DM
9. Collins
10. McClellan
11. Ottke

Hard to rank Ottke ahead of any of these guys

[Dan...]

I would go

1. Hopkins
2. Jones - sorry, Roy, you've been ousted in the last 3 years big time
3. Toney
4. Calzaghe
5. Tarver
6. Eubank
7. Benn
8. DM
9. Collins
10. McClellan
11. Ottke

Hard to rank Ottke ahead of any of these guys

I thought you would have rated Calzaghe lower than that tbh. My list is probably the exact same as yours with Roy and Bernard switched.

[phallus]

jones
toney
B-hop
calzaghe
eubank
benn
DM
collins
ottke

mclellan didn't have enough time to prove himself, and ottke has to be last because he needed the judges help to win most of his fights

[mspiegelo]

Here's the list. Rated in terms of skill AND accomplishments in the ring. McClellan is hard because his career ended so abruptly, but I'm sure you can deal! Go!!!!

THE CHOICES:

Ottke, Toney, Jones, Hopkins, Calzaghe, Benn, Eubank, Tarver, Michalczewski, Collins, McClellan


MY RATINGS:

1) Jones Jr.
2) Hopkins
3) Toney
4) Calzaghe
5) Benn
6) Eubank
7) Tarver
8) McClellan
9) Michalczewski
10) Collins
11) Ottke

with the jones jr. loss, i have to say that nothing changes. my list is in tact. if hopkins beats someone crazy like dawson or joe in a rematch in wales, he may be on the verge of taking over #1 just based on his longevity and whats he accomplished in his whole career.... then again, roy jones had considerable amateur accomplishments too, including multiple national titles, 250 amateur fights, and a silver medal that should have been a gold!