Rate these fighters in order of greatness (Jones, Calzaghe, Hopkins, Toney, & MORE!!)

[mspiegelo]

Here's the list. Rated in terms of skill AND accomplishments in the ring. McClellan is hard because his career ended so abruptly, but I'm sure you can deal! Go!!!!

THE CHOICES:

Ottke, Toney, Jones, Hopkins, Calzaghe, Benn, Eubank, Tarver, Michalczewski, Collins, McClellan


MY RATINGS:

1) Jones Jr.
2) Hopkins
3) Toney
4) Calzaghe
5) Benn
6) Eubank
7) Tarver
8) McClellan
9) Michalczewski
10) Collins
11) Ottke

[Silencers]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe
Eubank
Benn
Tarver
Michaelczewski
Collins
Ottke
McClellan

McClellan could have been up there but I can't put him above guys who accomplished much more than he did because of his injury obviously.

[mspiegelo]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe
Eubank
Benn
Tarver
Collins
McClellan

McClellan could have been up there but I can't put him above guys who accomplished much more than he did because of his injury obviously.

i feel ya bro. lol that darius and ottke don't even make your list. haha!

[WhoreUs]

1. jones
2. toney
3. benn
4. hopkins
5. calzaghe

i don't care enough to rank the rest however tarver is last.

[Motofan]

1) Jones
2) Hopkins
3) Calzaghe
4) Toney
5) Benn
6) Eubank
7) Tarver

I havent seen enough fights from 8-11 to rate them properly, so they could be above a couple of people I ranked.

[Silencers]

i feel ya bro. lol that darius and ottke don't even make your list. haha!

I forgot about them.

Michalczewski above Collins, Ottke above McClellan.

[Dambala]

1-Jones
2-B-Hop
3-Toney
4-Calzaghe
5-Eubank
6-Benn
7-Tarver
8-Michalczewski
9-Collins
10-McClelan
11-Ottke

[roundingace]

1. Jones

Everyone else is just chasing him. Nothing more to be said really.

[JAB5239]

Here's the list. Rated in terms of skill AND accomplishments in the ring. McClellan is hard because his career ended so abruptly, but I'm sure you can deal! Go!!!!

THE CHOICES:

Ottke, Toney, Jones, Hopkins, Calzaghe, Benn, Eubank, Tarver, Michalczewski, Collins, McClellan


MY RATINGS:

1) Jones Jr.
2) Hopkins
3) Toney
4) Calzaghe
5) Benn
6) Eubank
7) Tarver
8) McClellan
9) Michalczewski
10) Collins
11) Ottke

Jones Jr.
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe
Michalczewski
Collins
Benn
Eubank
Tarver
Ottke
McClellan

[BOLLOCKS]

1. Calzaghe
2. Hopkins
3. Jones Jr.