Rate these fighters in order of greatness (Jones, Calzaghe, Hopkins, Toney, & MORE!!)

[skyler]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe
Eubank
Benn
Tarver
Michaelczewski
Collins
McClellan

[tredh]

It's really pathetic how all Americans put Toney over Calzaghe.

Actually its not because its the truth. Toney is greater than Calzaghe.

[Kball15]

i would take calzaghe and remove him from the list. he doesnt deserve to be up there with names like Ottke!

[The Hammer]

Actually its not because its the truth. Toney is greater than Calzaghe.

Joe "The Welsh Dragon" Calzaghe is greater than James "Belly's Out" Toney.

[tito yuca]

Actually its not because its the truth. Toney is greater than Calzaghe.

No one who loses to Montell Griffin is better than Calzaghe.

[tredh]

Joe "The Welsh Dragon" Calzaghe is greater than James "Belly's Out" Toney.

Joe would have gotten his lights put out by a prime Toney.

No one who loses to Montell Griffin is better than Calzaghe.

This statement is to f^ckin ****** for a real response.

[TheGreatAli]

What the **** has Toney done in his career?

Answer = **** all.

[evilp0ptart]

I agree that a prime Toney would put a working on Calzaghe, and the Montell Griffin comment was just ******. Roy Jones lost to Griffin yet he has accomplished more than Calzaghe can hope to

[mspiegelo]

It's really pathetic how all Americans put Toney over Calzaghe.

if you go to espn and check out the roy interview, you will see that even roy agrees that james toney is the greatest fighter that he has or will fight. he repeated it to clarify that he felt toney was superior to calzaghe in his prime...

[tito yuca]

if you go to espn and check out the roy interview, you will see that even roy agrees that james toney is the greatest fighter that he has or will fight. he repeated it to clarify that he felt toney was superior to calzaghe in his prime...

No, he only said it to make himself look good because he gave him such a whoopin.

And to the idiot that said Roy lost to Montell Griffin, THAT'S the ******est comment I've ever seen. Montell Griffin ****** and he beat Toney. Period. Calzaghe, prime or no prime, would NEVER lose to someone of that caliber.