Rate these fighters in order of greatness (Jones, Calzaghe, Hopkins, Toney, & MORE!!)

[BennyST]

1. jones
2. toney
3. benn
4. hopkins
5. calzaghe

i don't care enough to rank the rest however tarver is last.

How is Benn above Hopkins, Calzaghe, Eubanks, Tarver, Michalczewski etc? He was a good exciting fighter, but, well, not really that good. If this were about "How do you rate these fighters by excitement?", then he would be up where you put him, but on skill and accomplishment? Just curious?

[KJB]

1. jones
2. toney
3. benn
4. hopkins
5. calzaghe

i don't care enough to rank the rest however tarver is last.

LOL at Benn being ahead of Hopkins, that nuts.
Jones, Hopkins and Toney are the top three.

[BennyST]

I can't be bothered thinking about this too much but I would put them somewhat like this:

Jones
Hopkins
Toney/Calzaghe (I can't decide between Calzaghe and Toney here, but I'm going on Calzaghe beating Jones, otherwise it would definitely be Toney. I give Toney a slight edge overall on accomplishments but of course he had those falls, which throw him a bit. Toney is still probably greater all 'round though)
Eubank
Michalczweski
Tarver
Benn
Ottke
Collins
McClellan

[KostyaTszyu44]

1. Dariusz
2. Calzaghe
3. Hopkins
4. Jones Jr.
5. Ottke
6. Collins
7. Eubank
8. Benn
9. James "Belly's Out" Toney
10. McClellan

lol nice try tunney


you havent seen much of a prime toney have you?

hes only fat today because hes old and a bit lazy really, watch him vs nunn, mccallum, barkely or jirov....those were some good performances

no one in their right mind would rank dariusz,ottke, collins, eubank, benn and calzaghe over toney

utter bull**** and you know it, rank the white fighters first as always

[KostyaTszyu44]

yea like another poster said, jones knows toney was the best he ever fought

toney is a brilliant fighter, calling him bellys out is just dumb...yeah hes fat now but hes ultra skilled

[Dawerlzgreatest]

It's really pathetic how all Americans put Toney over Calzaghe.

calslappy never was...and never will be on james level

[Scott9945]

I forgot about them.

Michalczewski above Collins, Ottke above McClellan.

Nobody else seems to remember that McClellan beat only one good fighter in his entire overrated career. His record doesn't even begin to compare to Michalczewski's.

[Silencers]

Nobody else seems to remember that McClellan beat only one good fighter in his entire overrated career. His record doesn't even begin to compare to Michalczewski's.

Definitely, as I said earlier, he could have been up there had he not gotten injured but what he accomplished was nowhere near what the other fighters on that list accomplished.

[MWMerlino]

Toney's belts from MW > HW are stronger than Calzaghe's reign with alphabet title.

Jones Jr.
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe

Juggle the rest

[-Swizzy-]

Jones Jr.
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe
Eubank
Benn
Tarver
DM
Ottke
McClellan
Collins