Calzaghe SMW greatest of all time?

[BLOODGOD]

Is joe SMW king who is undefeated and has a record of 44-0-32 is greatest SMW of all time?

[KingTito]

I think he'd lose to Roy or Toney at SMW.

[El Chicano]

No, just no.

[KnockoutTheFat]

Technically, yes, since most of his accomplishments were in that division, whereas RJJ just looked the best there but didn't unify the titles.

[Silencers]

Accomplishment wise, yes.

[Thread Stealer]

Yes. The division is new, barely 20 years old.

He's achieved the most at 168 of any fighter since then.

But as far as him at his best beating the Roy Jones of 1994-96 at 168 lbs?

No. Jones by UD.

[KnockoutTheFat]

Since when was the Roy Jones fight at SMW?

[Thread Stealer]

The upcoming fight with Jones has nothing to do with their all-time standings at 168.

[El Chicano]

With all the time he's spent in the division, he aint done ****. He beat an overrated Kessler and Lacy and lost to Hopkins. That's not "greatest" credentials.

[RJJp4pbaby]

Technically, yes, since most of his accomplishments were in that division, whereas RJJ just looked the best there but didn't unify the titles.

doesn't matter, he was a better fighter when he was at the same weight. smw was a ten year excuse for joe to play chicken.