Calzaghe SMW greatest of all time?

[ACHlLLES]

Yes he is, and anyone who votes any other way doesn't know **** about boxing. Both toney and roy didn't spend there whole entire career at super middle weight. So how the **** can they be better than him at that weight class??? Dumb asses

[BLOODGOD]

The upcoming fight with Jones has nothing to do with their all-time standings at 168.

His legacy will raise up to the highest lvl even roy is already past his prime.. IF he beats Roy ofcoarse..

[KnockoutTheFat]

The upcoming fight with Jones has nothing to do with their all-time standings at 168.

I know, which the reason why I'm wondering BLOODGOD *cough* Domain *cough* put it as one of the poll options.

[ACHlLLES]

His legacy will raise up to the highest lvl even roy is already past his prime.. IF he beats Roy ofcoarse..

The hell it will, his legacy wont.. This fight does nothing for joe if he wins at this point.

[bsrizpac]

His legacy will raise up to the highest lvl even roy is already past his prime.. IF he beats Roy ofcoarse..

Roy is shot. Godamn fanboys.

[Deadbirds]

No way ! Accomplishment ! Yes ! But who has he fought besides European Kessler who ffought no one ! Lacy who fought no one ! Toney would've Ko'd Calslappy ! Jones Jr. would've made him look silly ! And I believe Benn would've beat him !

[Thread Stealer]

His legacy will raise up to the highest lvl even roy is already past his prime.. IF he beats Roy ofcoarse..

No.

Roy is badly faded and a win does little for Calzaghe's all-time standing.

As for 168, it does NOTHING, as the fight is at light-heavy.

[Thread Stealer]

Yes he is, and anyone who votes any other way doesn't know **** about boxing. Both toney and roy didn't spend there whole entire career at super middle weight. So how the **** can they be better than him at that weight class??? Dumb asses

They're "better" at the weight class, but not "greater".

Lack of achievements/longevity there compared to Joe.

I think PBF and DLH beat Tszyu at 140, but Tszyu is "greater" at the division.

[ACHlLLES]

.....

[BLOODGOD]

Roy is shot. Godamn fanboys.

Are you shouting on your monitor while typing this? I see saliva at your screen pls wipe it out..