If RJJ beats JC, does he move onto the P4P list?

[roundingace]

Before losing to Tarver in the rematch, few had anyone ranked higher P4P than RJJ. He loses back to back KO's so he arguably gets booted off the list. BUT - should he beat Calzaghe, that would be 4-0 in his comebacks since losing those two. A for sure HOF'er in Tito and the undefeated JC? What do you guys think. IMO he goes to at least top 5, I'm not sure where I would put him, but he would be up there.

[Silencers]

He will for me.

[roundingace]

Those who think he will not make it back on the top 10, please explain. This isn't a bash you thread if you disagree, I would just like to see the logic behind it.

[Ramamaiden]

he should be, beating the number 2 p4p must guarantee you that. at least he would be on my list

[Mojita]

you beat the number 2 P4P rated fighter. you should be in top 5.

BUT

you beat number 1 slapper in the world ; you get bumped to top10.

[MANGLER]

A win over the #3 guy definitely gets him a spot.

[DannYankee]

He does on my book since im a fan and defeating Calzaghe is not a has been accomplishment its something that some of the best have failed at.

[Dambala]

Yeah should be at the top 5.

[shynequasiog22]

If Margarito is on there for beating Cotto then there's no question that Roy is on. Who thought they could possibly see Roy and Bhop both on the P4P list again?

[luv3s2sp00g3]

I'm not so sure if he deserves to be on there, but hear me out.

First off, I wanna say RJJ is my top 2 favorite boxers ALLTIME, the other being Tyson. So by no means am I saying this cos I'm a hater or anything. (Yes I'm betting on Calzaghe over RJJ too according to my sig but thats only cos RJJ is old).

Everybody else on the top 10 P4P right now has at least a couple of notable wins or has been on some sort of streak.

Roy hasn't done anything significant for a looong time. I mean, check his last five fights for yourself. Prince Badi Ajamu? Anthony Hanshaw? If he beats Calzaghe, I wouldn't take anything away from RJJ, cos I'm a Calzaghe fan myself, so yeah that would be a huge feat. Just saying, I wouldn't feel right knocking off a lot of these guys on the top 10 right now who have had really good streaks going against really strong competition. Cos then its like saying just beating Calzaghe is a bigger accomplishment than those wins.