talyors resume is already 10 times better than joes

[BrooklynBomber]

YOu have got to be kidding me if you think that Wright and Pavlik are better then Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler, etc....
Guys like Ouma and Spinks should not be taken into an equation at all, both of them were put in to Make Taylor look good, and he failed to do so on both occasions.

[rizkybizness]

Im in a thread stating that I think Joe Calzaghe has a better resume than Jermain Taylor.

Well **** me mate, bring in the men in white coats and strap me down. I must be ****in insane

Insane in the membrane.......... INSANE IN THE BRAIN

[abadger]

With that post in mind we are now absolutely certain that Taylor's resumé is at least 10 times greater than Calzaghe's.

Regards
flawless, larryx, ragingvic, thadrow, Tengoshi and probably more.

[krispy kreme]

YOu have got to be kidding me if you think that Wright and Pavlik are better then Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler, etc....
Guys like Ouma and Spinks should not be taken into an equation at all, both of them were put in to Make Taylor look good, and he failed to do so on both occasions.

Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler are all better than Wright?

[BrooklynBomber]

Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler are all better than Wright?

Outside of Bika(and maybe Lacy, although that one is very questionable, pre Joe Lacy beats Wright, imo) they would all have a fun time picking powerless, stationary target like Wright.


But I am talking as a sum of all these defenses, drawing with a good, but out of prime fighter is not gonna be counted as much as beating these five.
No matter how you swing it.

[Kris Silver]

Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler are all better than Wright?

Certainly accumulated yes. Eubank even at that age may well have beaten him, Kessler just plain would, Bika and Reid would be close but he'd beat them probably. Kessler would beat him, he's SMW #1. Lacy Joe humiliated. What is likely is that if he faced them all he'd come away with more losses, unlike Joe.

[abadger]

Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler are all better than Wright?

I think a case can be made that Eubank, Kessler and even Reid were better than the Wright that Taylor fought. You are conveniently overlooking the fact that Wright was some way past his best. Plus, Taylor didn't actually win, whereas Calzaghe did against all those guys.

Besides which, that isn't the question is it? Whether one of Taylor's opponents is better than some of Calzaghe's opponents is irrelevant, the question is resume and Calzaghe wins hands down.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Eubank, Lacy, Reid, Bika, Kessler are all better than Wright?

I would say beating Eubank and Kessler convincingly is better than getting a very unconvincing draw with Winky.

I dont think Winky at 160 was as good as he was lower down either

[rizkybizness]

Outside of Bika(and maybe Lacy, although that one is very questionable, pre Joe Lacy beats Wright, imo) they would all have a fun time picking powerless, stationary target like Wright.


But I am talking as a sum of all these defenses, drawing with a good, but out of prime fighter is not gonna be counted as much as beating these five.
No matter how you swing it.

A pre Joe Lacy beats Wright????????????!!!!!!?!?!

Are you insane?

[krispy kreme]

I think a case can be made that Eubank, Kessler and even Reid were better than the Wright that Taylor fought. You are conveniently overlooking the fact that Wright was some way past his best. Plus, Taylor didn't actually win, whereas Calzaghe did against all those guys.

Besides which, that isn't the question is it? Whether one of Taylor's opponents is better than some of Calzaghe's opponents is irrelevant, the question is resume and Calzaghe wins hands down.

Outside of Bika(and maybe Lacy, although that one is very questionable, pre Joe Lacy beats Wright, imo) they would all have a fun time picking powerless, stationary target like Wright.


But I am talking as a sum of all these defenses, drawing with a good, but out of prime fighter is not gonna be counted as much as beating these five.
No matter how you swing it.

Certainly accumulated yes. Eubank even at that age may well have beaten him, Kessler just plain would, Bika and Reid would be close but he'd beat them probably. Kessler would beat him, he's SMW #1. Lacy Joe humiliated. What is likely is that if he faced them all he'd come away with more losses, unlike Joe.

Thanks for the replies guys, but I can't agree with **** your saying. I just believe Wright is the superior boxer to all those guys.