The Top 3, who's better? Shane, Oscar, Tito?

[The Surgeon]

[/U]


Please. That fight was not even as close as the scorecards indicated. Mosley clearly beat Delahoya and if their was any doubt he kicked Oscars ass in the last round. Try actually watching the fight instead of cheerleading Delahoya.

I had it a clear win Sugar too

[joseph5620]

He didn't soften **** up for De La Hoya.. That was only ONE loss for Vargas AND Tito had to do it hitting him to the balls 6+ times.

Apparently you didnt see the first round of that fight. Vargas got the **** kicked out of him that night regardless of low blows.

[joseph5620]

Judging by thier fiights against Mayorga and Vargas, who do u think is better?

All fights were at 154, less Tito vs Ricardo (which was fought at 160lbs, I think, giving Tito the advantage).

Who's performances were better? Who deserves to be ranked highest?

Remember, Shane is 37.

IMO Oscar ranks below both. That gutless retreat against Trinidad and making Hopkins sign a contract to weigh no more than 157 is enough for me. Also, Mosley is not afraid to compete with top fighters like Cotto and Collazo at an older age. Oscar is a part time fighter looking for paydays and gimmick fights while trying to come in with advantages regarding the weight.

[joseph5620]

[QUOTE=Puas;4123100]Oscar had the easier time with Mayorga and stopped Vargas one round sooner than Tito. Vargas gave Tito all he could handle. Tito looked beat up and spent after the Fernando fight.

Vargas gave Delahoya all he could handle too. Delahoya didn't come out of that unscathed. Sometimes I wonder what fights some of you were watching. Vargas took a beating from Trinidad and I have a hard time believing he was the same fighter after that fight. Mentally or physically. I 'll also add that Delahoya made no effort to fight Vargas until after her saw him lose.

[Pullcounter]

Judging by thier fiights against Mayorga and Vargas, who do u think is better?

All fights were at 154, less Tito vs Ricardo (which was fought at 160lbs, I think, giving Tito the advantage).

Who's performances were better? Who deserves to be ranked highest?

Remember, Shane is 37.

styles make fights...

on a whole i think tito was better overall but dlh had more skills than both while mosley was just more athletic and faster than dlh.

tito did beat dlh and imho tito would beat mosley.

tito deserves a lot of credit for ruining vargas and mayorga.

[Da7thsign]

Against both Mayo and Vargas, its Tito then Oscar then Shane. But overall better boxer, Shane and Oscar tie and Tito is last.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

In terms of downright skill, it would have to be Shane…he can ****, he can box, he can counter
In terms of drawing power, we all know who that goes to..Oscar can fight a ham sandwich and people would pay
In terms of devastating entertainment, its Tito…when he get’s dropped, we know its actually his wake-up call and his opponent is about to get checked

[Thread Stealer]

Based on their performances against Vargas and Mayorga:

Trinidad, then DLH, then Mosley.

Overall standing:

DLH, then Trinidad, then Mosley.

I can see Trinidad being ahead of DLH, but Mosley is third despite his success against DLH. His overall body of work is the weakest.