The Top 3, who's better? Shane, Oscar, Tito?

[El Chicano]

Judging by thier fiights against Mayorga and Vargas, who do u think is better?

All fights were at 154, less Tito vs Ricardo (which was fought at 160lbs, I think, giving Tito the advantage).

Who's performances were better? Who deserves to be ranked highest?

Remember, Shane is 37.

[Rompeboca]

Tito cuz he soften them both for DLH!

[AntDawg]

Oscar. He destroyed them both of them with ease.

[sylvestersweet]

I voted Shane 'cause I didn't see what you said about each's respective performance against Mayorga.
In that case, Tito did best.

[Silencers]

DLH should have gotten a decision over both of them but didn't, accomplishments at 147 Trinidad, DLH, Mosley.

[Dambala]

Tito fought an undefeated and hungrier Vargas, he destroyed him, Tito fought a Mayorga on steroids and beat him too, then Oscar fought them both. Same case with Yori Boy Campas and Oba Carr.

Tito,Oscar, Shane

[El Chicano]

Oscar had the easier time with Mayorga and stopped Vargas one round sooner than Tito. Vargas gave Tito all he could handle. Tito looked beat up and spent after the Fernando fight. While Oscar vs Vargas was competitive, Oscar didn't have as hard a time with Vargas as it appeared Tito did. And Fernando was on steriods against Oscar.

So I voted Oscar. And like Silencers stated above, I believe he should have got the nod against Tito and Shane in the second fight. (Maybe even the first, it was damn close).

[BlackHat]

Tito fought an undefeated and hungrier Vargas, he destroyed him, Tito fought a Mayorga on steroids and beat him too, then Oscar fought them both. Same case with Yori Boy Campas and Oba Carr.

Tito,Oscar, Shane

Tito destroyed Fernando's balls.

Shane
Tito
Oscar

[The Surgeon]

oF ALL oSCAR AND tITO'S COMMON OPPENENTS tRINIDAD FOUGHT BETTER VERSIONS

[poeticlsykuac]

I'd say pound for pound Shane is the best of the three. DLH is the best if you look at resume/accomplishments. Tito had unreal power at 147, but by no means would I consider him anything special outside of that. His boxing skills very limited and any jab disrupted him(very one dimensional). He was a ball puncher, he saved himself a KO against Vargas from it. Sorry for all you out there that don't agree. I just think that Vargas was becoming dominant when that low blow happened and it was obvious that took a lot out of him.

Shane
DLH
Tito

Shane was just so much smaller then the 2 I just think his accomplishments were more difficult to attain.