Is #2 Too High a Spot for Calzaghe on the P4P List?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Here, I'll make it easier for you: Shut up moron.

Do you ever post about boxing?

[MoneyMay]

Hater! I think he should be granted the #1 spot in perpetuity.

And yet I voted for him to be #1, he is first on Boxrec I believe, the last time I checked which is quite credible.

[abadger]

And yet I voted for him to be #1, he is first on Boxrec I believe, the last time I checked which is quite credible.

Hey, I was just kidding.

[Tmb04]

I dont think so. And the sad part is, if he beats a washed up Jones and Pacman loses to a man 3 times his size that Calzaghe will be number 1. I personally think top 5 maybe but When Marquez wins impressively against Casamayor I think he'll deserve the number 2 rank

[krispy kreme]

How did Sin get banned?

[egreezy]

I dont think so. And the sad part is, if he beats a washed up Jones and Pacman loses to a man 3 times his size that Calzaghe will be number 1. I personally think top 5 maybe but When Marquez wins impressively against Casamayor I think he'll deserve the number 2 rank

not necessarily pavlik can jump to #1 if he beats hopkins. i can see that pissing joe off

[abadger]

not necessarily pavlik can jump to #1 if he beats hopkins. i can see that pissing joe off

How does Pavlik get to #1 for beating Hopkins? Calzaghe beat him when he was still the Ring champ at LHW and made it to #2. There is no conceivable way you can possibly justify what you just said.

[egreezy]

How does Pavlik get to #1 for beating Hopkins? Calzaghe beat him when he was still the Ring champ at LHW and made it to #2. There is no conceivable way you can possibly justify what you just said.

If he beats him in better fashion, looks more impressive then Calzaghe. Wider decision, KO, TKO. After that win Pavlik's resume will be better then Joes. Since that was his toughest win.

[Dan...]

How does Pavlik get to #1 for beating Hopkins? Calzaghe beat him when he was still the Ring champ at LHW and made it to #2. There is no conceivable way you can possibly justify what you just said.

Pavlik is an American you dumb ****. Educate yourself.


I think Joe deserves the number 2 spot, but I don't think he should go to number 1, even if he beats Roy and Manny loses to Oscar. Pacquiao has beaten 3 genuinely elite p4p fighters in Morales, MAB and JMM of late, that has to override the events of the next few months, regardless of what they may be. For Joe to go to number one he would need to beat a Dawson or a Pavlik and Manny would need to lose to a fighter around his own weight class. That is my take on it anyway.

[abadger]

If he beats him in better fashion, looks more impressive then Calzaghe. Wider decision, KO, TKO. After that win Pavlik's resume will be better then Joes. Since that was his toughest win.

*sighs..........*

There is no conceivable way you can possibly justify what you just said.