Pavlik resume nearly good as Calzaghe

[Flawless]

Who makes up these rules??? You're an absolute joke. Calzaghe fought an older Hopkins than Taylor. And now Pavlik is fighting an even older Hopkins but you argue theres no difference?

Calzaghe fought Hopkins 2 years after Taylor fact. Pavlik is fighting Hopkins 6 months later. 2 years or 6 months

[squealpiggy]

Do you think Jermaine Taylor could beat Kessler?

[The Hammer]

Calzaghe also defeated:

Byron Mitchell, two-time world champion
Charles Brewer, world champion and tough as nails
Omar Sheika, who was coming off a win over Glen Johnson
Robin Reid, world champion

Jeff Lacy was a world titleholder with a good chin, and was definitely better than the china-chinned Miranda!

[Flawless]

Do you think Jermaine Taylor could beat Kessler?

Of course I do. I don't think a basic boxer like Kessler would be able to beat Hopkins

[Flawless]

Calzaghe also defeated:

Byron Mitchell, two-time world champion
Charles Brewer, world champion and tough as nails
Omar Sheika, who was coming off a win over Glen Johnson
Robin Reid, world champion

Jeff Lacy was a world titleholder with a good chin, and was definitely better than the china-chinned Miranda!

Anyone can be a world champion. Mundine had a SMW title, you think he would be able to win a MW now

[Dan...]

Of course I do. I don't think a basic boxer like Kessler would be able to beat Hopkins

Not giving Kessler anywhere near enough credit. But hey, I guess you are a ****n moron.

[M.I Truth ?]

I know this wont be popular but I think he is right. To me Joe's best win was hopkins witch is very impressive. Pavlik's best win is Taylor who beat Joe's best win twice. If Pavlik beat Hopkins (witch there is up in the air) then his resume in on par with Joe's. The whole thing of Kessler being better than Taylor is interesting to me because I feel Taylor has the bigger wins and made it through two tough matches with Hopkins. Kessler is good but I think he needs another big fight to see how good.

[Flawless]

Kessler was unproven when Calzaghe fought him, his best win was Mundine
Taylor was proven beating Hopkins twice

[Dan...]

I know this wont be popular but I think he is right. To me Joe's best win was hopkins witch is very impressive. Pavlik's best win is Taylor who beat Joe's best win twice. If Pavlik beat Hopkins (witch there is up in the air) then his resume in on par with Joe's. The whole thing of Kessler being better than Taylor is interesting to me because I feel Taylor has the bigger wins and made it through two tough matches with Hopkins. Kessler is good but I think he needs another big fight to see how good.

Triangle theories fail at life.

[M.I Truth ?]

Triangle theories fail at life.

When talking about resume's its valid until the parties fight each other.