Is Felix Trinidad an ATG ???

[Flawless]

This spray has no affect what so ever

[JAB5239]

Not in the top 50 without a doubt

Maybe. Maybe not, my man. But even if he is top 100 he still has to be considered an all time great.

[El Dominicano]

There is no reason to bash Tito. Whats there to hate about him?? The only thing Tito did that I disliked was him retiring after a lost.

[Flawless]

Maybe. Maybe not, my man. But even if he is top 100 he still has to be considered an all time great.

There is a difference between HOFer and ATG, There isn’t 100 ATG.

[Flawless]

There is no reason to bash Tito. Whats there to hate about him?? The only thing Tito did that I disliked was him retiring after a lost.

I am not dislking him, but no way he is an ATG. His name shouldn’t be up there with Duran Ali Leonard Robinson Marciano

[JAB5239]

There is a difference between HOFer and ATG, There isn’t 100 ATG.

No disrespect, but thats crazy talk. There have been thousands upon thousands of fighters in the history of boxing. If you are considered one of the top 100 best, you're an all time great.

[TheGreatA]

What is your definition of ATG?

[El Dominicano]

I am not dislking him, but no way he is an ATG. His name shouldn’t be up there with Duran Ali Leonard Robinson Marciano

Please...Please don't say Marciano. I hate it when the media mentions

"Great fighters like Marciano, Ali and SRR" Even the news spits it out like that. **** I don't wana disrespect Marciano but he isn't GREAT. I could name a bunch of H.W's right now who would have been undefeated if faced with the same opponents.

[JAB5239]

I am not dislking him, but no way he is an ATG. His name shouldn’t be up there with Duran Ali Leonard Robinson Marciano

I wouldn't rank him near the first 4 names you mentioned. But did he not do almost exactly what Marciano did, minus retiring undefeated? He beat the best at 147 and 154. He got a gift against Oscar, but the same can be said about Marciano in the first LaStarza fight. They both cleaned out divisions. They both beat faded legends. It might be sacrilidge to compare the two, but if you take a realistic look at things they are comparable.

[El Dominicano]

I wouldn't rank him near the first 4 names you mentioned. But did he not do almost exactly what Marciano did, minus retiring undefeated? He beat the best at 147 and 154. He got a gift against Oscar, but the same can be said about Marciano in the first LaStarza fight. They both cleaned out divisions. They both beat faded legends. It might be sacrilidge to compare the two, but if you take a realistic look at things they are comparable.

*Sigh* Don't wana get jumped on but I feel Tito has done more.