Who here actually thinks Williams can beat Margarito in a rematch?

[Mr. Philadel]

yes he does, just as many if not more punches... constant movement, and a great chin as well...

constant movement bothers margarito... he doesnt throw until the opponent usually stops moving

Good eye...I noticed that to!

[Derranged]

If Williams boxes Margarito the way he did first time out, he will beat him again. He was able to do what Cotto couldn't, evade Maragarito's destructive power for long enough to get a decsion win.

If Williams tries to box Margarito the way he did Quintana both times then he will lose.

Not to mention he takes a better punch than Cotto. Williams should win this fight. I'll bet points on it.

[Gareth Ivanovic]

It will be a good fight and I expect Tony to come out guns a blazin. I think Williams being a southpaw and his ridiculous length give Margarito trouble combined with his huge punch output. In the first fight it was like Paul's punch output was his defense as well because Marg couldn't get into punching range. Plus Paul had enough movement to confuse Margarito a little bit and also he held at good times.

[Burner]

Williams has the style that will always beat Margarito..no way around it..I dont care how many times they fight Williams wil beat him.

[Spirit]

Wow I didn't expect people to be this divided about a rematch.

But please explain to me why Williams' chin is that great, because as far as I can tell it hasn't really been tested yet. You can't compare his chin to Cotto's merely because Cotto has faced much bigger punchers than Williams has, aside from Margarito that is. I've seen Margarito hurt Williams on the inside though.

[C'MONMANG']

Cuz I don't see it happening. Even though I'm convinced this fight will have to take place in order to determine a true WW champ, I don't see Williams standing much of a chance. Note: I don't think the decision in their first fight was controversial, PW did enough to win. I just don't see Tony falling for the same trap twice.

Don't get me wrong I'm not biased towards any of these fighters, but the only thing I've seen Williams impose his opponents with is his freakish physical attributes. I don't believe they were much of an advantage even in the first fight. The only thing Williams cleverly did to win the fight was throw in volumes for 12 rounds straight. Tony hurt PW, but was hesistant to push the fight due to PW's punch output.

With revenge on his mind, a big payday, another title and confidence boost from his win last saturday I think Tony will stop him

Toss up if Margarito starts fast..

[Fenom]

its a tough one to call but just as Marg will make the adjustment to start faster.......i think Williams will the make the proper adjustments as well to ensure the win.

he's got all the tools to beat him again.....especially if he improves his stamina

[Luciano]

Wow I didn't expect people to be this divided about a rematch.

But please explain to me why Williams' chin is that great, because as far as I can tell it hasn't really been tested yet. You can't compare his chin to Cotto's merely because Cotto has faced much bigger punchers than Williams has, aside from Margarito that is. I've seen Margarito hurt Williams on the inside though.

What?? If you want to talk about overrated and beating a bunch of nobodies start with the guy in your av. Margarito never hurt Williams to the body, never once did Williams stop punching and his body language say he was hurt, of course haymakers to the body caused him to hunch, but right away he responded with punches and movement. Cotto looked hurt 100 times vs Margarito and Williams never looked hurt once. Matthysse isn't a big enough puncher for you?? If Cotto took the shots Williams did vs him he would've quit again.

Williams is bigger, faster, a better boxer, has more volume with his punches, more looks and angles to give, just as good a chin, and power is equal in my opinion when Williams sits on his punches. He'll beat Margarito 99.9 times out of 100. What edge does Margarito have?? He is tough and keeps coming, but he's slow and plodding. Williams EASY all day.

[Sox8055]

Margarito by late stoppage or UD, this time Tony will start faster and take his punches like he did against Cotto hell pressure the punisher. If Quintana was able to cut the punisher then tony can so to with his power punches, he learned his lesson once, wont repeat it again...

[tuts]

williams wins this fight marg isnt going to be able to over welm williams with his punch out put. plus his taking more punishment than williams has in his couple of fights not good long term for his career