Who here actually thinks Williams can beat Margarito in a rematch?

[Spirit]

Matthysse lost to Williams and Cintron...therefore he obviously isn't a big puncher. And you see my worth?? Williams fought Margarito in his backyard. And beat him easy. He has basically no amateur career, still is green, and Margarito has been fighting pro since what?? 16?? After outboxing him easily, Margarito did what he did to Cotto, started pouring it on trying to impose his will. The difference is Williams fought back, and came out to dominate the 12th cementing his win. I thought he won 9 rounds.

Seriously...what?! Where exactly did I say Williams isn't a big puncher in that post? Are you actually reading what I'm posting, cuz if not please stop replying. Did you see those Williams fights? I've seen people post some very good reasons for Williams to win a rematch, but he did not beat Tony easilly. If he did the scorecards would have had him ahead by a much wider margin instead of 115-113 and 116-112 (twice). Hell, it'd be hard to find someone that scored it the way you did. If you thought he won 9 rounds then I guess I was right about you in my first reply.

It doesn't get anymore dominate then that. Compare that performance vs Quintana to Cotto's performance vs him. Williams will only get better and better.

No top 10 fighter fights his opponents the same way and whether it's Williams blowing him away in 1 round or Cotto beating him up and making him quit on his stool in 5

[Luciano]

Seriously...what?! Where exactly did I say Williams isn't a big puncher in that post? Are you actually reading what I'm posting, cuz if not please stop replying. Did you see those Williams fights? I've seen people post some very good reasons for Williams to win a rematch, but he did not beat Tony easilly. If he did the scorecards would have had him ahead by a much wider margin instead of 115-113 and 116-112 (twice). Hell, it'd be hard to find someone that scored it the way you did. If you thought he won 9 rounds then I guess I was right about you in my first reply.


No top 10 fighter fights his opponents the same way and whether it's Williams blowing him away in 1 round or Cotto beating him up and making him quit on his stool in 5

Hahaha so the official scorecards is what you go by?? Did you actually think Chavez beat Whitaker?? Williams won the first 6 rounds, and the 12th, you didn't give him any betwen 7-11??? Get the **** outta here.

[Spirit]

Williams took his best shots to the head and body and barely blinked. He came out and won the 12th round easy. I just broke it down. Maybe now you will get it.

I've seen the fight and what you're saying is lie to anyone with half their vision.
I think it would've hurt him if he blinked I mean he did get cut

[DuttyAlacrity]

I see it happening Williams can do it again

[Luciano]

I've seen the fight and what you're saying is lie to anyone with half their vision.
I think it would've hurt him if he blinked I mean he did get cut

Okay. Then let's see how you scored it. The fact you bring up a cut already shows me how you score fights.

What rounds did you give to Margarito?? Did you give him the 12th?? Haha. What of the first 6 did you give him??

[Fenom]

Luciano where u at?

[Luciano]

I'm right here, what's good?

[Fenom]

oh u musta just sigged.....aight

[TheSurgeonMDMPH]

I can't see Margie beating fighters of his size or greater due to the loss of his obvious advantages at ww. PW nulls all the advantages he has except chin but that only means he will use less D and more chin which doesn't win fights! PW by UD!

[deanrw]

Williams with his size, work rate and chin, negates much of the advantages Margarito has over opponents.

They could fight 10 times and come out 5-5 each. I notice Williams get knocked on in here a lot and it makes no sense to me. He and Margarito both throw a million punches, both have vulnerabilities, both are tough as nails and both will fight anyone.

I like them both. How someone can be a fan of one of them and not the other puzzles me.