Skills Break-Down Poll: Jones vs. Calzaghe

[THE REED]

When and if the fight happens I will bet you my entire points.
Roy is done and dusted.
You still dream of him in 2003.
Roy has had ****e performances against nobodies like Prince jaffie joffie and against an old blown up welter called Tito who wanted a payday.
Why isnt Roy challenging young blood ?
Or Tarver or Johnson or Hopkins etc etc etc etc?
Ever asked yourself why ?
Calzaghe offers the retirement fund even if he gets ktfo.

i appreciate your harsh criticism of my opinions.. and i feel flattered you seem to care so much about why i think what i think...

but come fight time.. roy wont be hitting the canvas, and your biased fogged vision, will lead all your points to my bankroll...

roy wont be getting knocked out..

[THE REED]

I can only help you narrow the selections.

We pretty much know who's faster, who has a better chin, who's the better boxer and who has better stamina.

what shall we doo... im counting on u lol... ya i dont want it to be an obvious poll

[MANGLER]

RJ ain't as fast as he used to be, Joe C gets the edge. Jones does have more power. Joe C throws a ****load of punches, RJ conserves energy and picks his shots. Cuz of that, I'd give RJ the edge even tho neither one has ever looked gassed badly except Roy in the 1st Tarver fight, and Joe a lil bit against Hopkins. Joe C is reckless as hell cuz he's got a good chin he ain't afraid to use. Roy is way more cautious cuz he's been KO'd before. Roy gets the defense nod too. Based on the chooseable poll criteria, I say RJ wins, even tho it's winnable for either guy.

[Silencers]

what shall we doo... im counting on u lol... ya i dont want it to be an obvious poll

lol.

I think their power, offense and intangibles are least clear cut topics between them.

[THE REED]

lol.

I think their power, offense and intangibles are least clear cut topics between them.

i dont like the intangible selection


cuz marg might have a better chin but cotto might have more heart


lets edit this list


Heart
Stamina
Offensive Arsenal
Defense

[Silencers]

i dont like the intangible selection


cuz marg might have a better chin but cotto might have more heart


lets edit this list


Heart
Stamina
Offensive Arsenal
Defense

Those selections are good, I do think 1 punch power between them is debatable though.

[THE REED]

alright i took your picks... you should be flattered

[Silencers]

alright i took your picks... you should be flattered

lol Thanks, I am.

I need to think over my answers.....

[Gatti9783]

Wow some people gave the Calzaghe the nod in regards to Speed? That's surprising...

[THE REED]

Wow some people gave the Calzaghe the nod in regards to Speed? That's surprising...

on this forum.... nothing is surprising

roy is 39 though