Who is the best current LHW?

[slicksouthpaw16]

You know I agree with you that Dawson actually is the best of the current crop at LHW, but the fact remains that Calzaghe has the best win at the weight. Yes Hopkins was 43 but he was the Ring champ and he was the highest ranked LHW. Basically its as simple as that.

Dawson has more, but Calzaghe has the best. Shouldn't really have called you biased though, sorry.

No problem at all , feel free to state your opinion. Thats what we are here for.

[Kastrioti]

I don't see how it's out of the question for Calzaghe to be #1.

[Lord13]

I don't see how it's out of the question for Calzaghe to be #1.

Look at the poll, many consider him to be #1.
Only guys like Slick have him at number 2 which is OK because I respect his opinion.

[Kastrioti]

Look at the poll, many consider him to be #1.
Only guys like Slick have him at number 2 which is OK because I respect his opinion.

So do I, but I'm just wondering why "it makes no sense" to have Calzaghe #1 in his opinion.

[Jim Jeffries]

it's up for grabs at the moment i consider the title at lhw vacant since tarver lost to hopkins cause hopkins was not the best lhw and joe calzaghe isn't either.they should have a tounament just like the heavys should

Wait, so you considered Tarver the #1 LHW, and he was smoked by Hopkins, and Hopkins was beaten by Calzaghe. But now they should have a tournament because you don't like Calzaghe?

[Alec900]

Calzaghe beat the man (Hopkins)....that beat the man (Tarver)....that beat the man (Jones)....that never beat the man (Michalczewski).

so...that makes Zsolt Erdei the best lhw?he beat the man (gonzalez) who beat the man (michalczewski)
sweet