Whitttaker was much better than Mayweather ever was

[cuzfozzy]

[MANGLER]

Sweet Pea was the ****in man in his day. PBF ain't got nothin on him or Roy.

[dino]

whitaker is overrated, throwing a few punchers per round doesn't empress me. whitaker had less talent then zab judah

[Bad_Barracuda]

No way.

Floyd has more firepower,is physically stronger and more disciplined outside the ring.

[cuzfozzy]

whittaker would never duck a cotto ...
he even fought trinidad and de la hoya (in his prime)
mayweather beats a one dimensional hatton and
thinks he just beat foreman ... lol

[ALT-Assassin]

whittaker would never duck a cotto ...
he even fought trinidad and de la hoya (in his prime)
mayweather beats a one dimensional hatton and
thinks he just beat foreman ... lol

Floyd had a more diverse offensive arsenal and was overall the better tactician but resume wise sweet pea ****s on him !

[MELLY-MEL...]

whitaker beat floyd prime for prime.

[ALT-Assassin]

whitaker beat floyd prime for prime.

50/50 fight

[MELLY-MEL...]

50/50 fight

no, it's not! pea wins 8-4

[Silencers]

Skillwise, it's very close. Resume wise, Whitaker definitely wins. I think Whitaker would have eeked out a win prime for prime.