Better Resume: Floyd Jr. vs Calzaghe

[THE REED]

Whose got the better Resume?

I ask because, in my honest opinion, Floyd has a better resume than Joe... YET... because Floyd is retiring, people wont place him near the top because he has a weak resume... which i dont really have a problem with...

But I think Floyds resume is stronger than Joe's... Yet Joe will be celebrated with his retirement, and resume... but not Floyd?

[THE REED]

Are floyds win over Oscar and Ricky, better than Joes wins over Bernard and possibly Roy?

[Ryn0]

Whose got the better Resume?

I ask because, in my honest opinion, Floyd has a better resume than Joe... YET... because Floyd is retiring, people wont place him near the top because he has a weak resume... which i dont really have a problem with...

But I think Floyds resume is stronger than Joe's... Yet Joe will be celebrated with his retirement, and resume... but not Floyd?

People won't place Floyd high because he didn't fight Cotto, there is no demand for Calzaghe to fight anyone but Pavlik and considering he's 37 (almost) it will be forgiven and the demand isn't anywhere near as high.

Calzaghe is retireing at the end of his career. Floyd is retiring the (what should be) the best days of his career, no real reason cited.

It's not fair but hey.

[rizkybizness]

Calzaghe aint ****.

End of thread.

[Live Dog]

Yes Floyd's resume is better than Calzaghe's.

Are floyds win over Oscar and Ricky, better than Joes wins over Bernard and possibly Roy?

Too close to call.

[Guest]

Reed, just because some people say dumb things do you really have to make polls to get them to state the obvious?

The answer is obviously Danny Williams.

[Silencers]

Mayweather's resume is better.

[THE REED]

Reed, just because some people say dumb things do you really have to make polls to get them to state the obvious?

The answer is obviously Danny Williams.

apparently.. i can do whatever the hell i want... :roy4:

[rizkybizness]

I'd have to go with Floyd "make it rain on dem hoez" Mayweather on this one. I feel he's faced the tougher opposition.

[T-97]

Floyd has a better resume. He has won multiple titles across 5 weight classes and Joe only 2. IMO Floyd wins hands down.