James Toney a ATG?

[Steak]

Toney never won a heavyweight title.....But yeah, I think he is still an ATG.

oh damn, youre right...it got changed to a NC. nice job there. he beat heavyweights champs tho, that has to mean something

[Boogie Nights]

The weight issues, steroids, almost losing to Dave Tiberi, losing to Thadzi etc.



It'll always be a draw and a no contest on his record.

i find it strange silencers how you took probably the most undisciplned fighter in the whole history of boxing, Max Bear, and labelled him an all time great yet you wont give the same praise to james

id also match toney's credentials against walcotts any day of the week...

[Silencers]

i find it strange silencers how you took probably the most undisciplned fighter in the whole history of boxing, Max Bear, and labelled him an all time great yet you wont give the same praise to james

id also match toney's credentials against walcotts any day of the week...

I never said Baer was an all time great.

[Atnan]

James Toney is the ****ing Truth-

[Boogie Nights]

I never said Baer was an all time great.

i could dig up 2 quotes where you clearly said he was...

[Silencers]

i could dig up 2 quotes where you clearly said he was...

I said it was arguable, same with Toney.

[Boogie Nights]

I said it was arguable, same with Toney.

im looking for them right now, and i will find them

[Silencers]

im looking for them right now, and i will find them

Go ahead.....

[Boogie Nights]

Go ahead.....

Walcott definitely is. Baer is debatable but I'll say yes.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=188124 Post #6

that's the first one

then there's another one which i remember where you stated that baer was great without using words like 'debatable' and flat out stated it

that's actually in my other thread but it's over 10 pages long

[Silencers]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=188124 Post #6

that's the first one

then there's another one which i remember where you stated that baer was great without using words like 'debatable' and flat out stated it

that's actually in my other thread but it's over 10 pages long

As I said, it's debatable.