James Toney a ATG?

[Dorian]

Is James Toney a all time great(ATG)
I think so, please vote

[Silencers]

I don't think so, too erratic and undisciplined IMO.

But he definitely could have been an ATG.

[TheManchine]

yes absolutely in my opinion

[Dan...]

I think he has to be an ATG.

[Steak]

name me a middleweight champ who won a heavyweight title who isnt an ATG

[Dan...]

I don't think so, too erratic and undisciplined IMO.

But he definitely could have been an ATG.

Silencers what does this mean? Are you talking about weight issues and the like?

Not questioning your opinion just would like some clarification.

[KESSLER]

Yes sir... No doubt.

[WLAD OWNS]

name me a middleweight champ who won a heavyweight title who isnt an ATG

Toney never won a heavyweight title.....But yeah, I think he is still an ATG.

[Silencers]

Silencers what does this mean? Are you talking about weight issues and the like?

Not questioning your opinion just would like some clarification.

The weight issues, steroids, almost losing to Dave Tiberi, losing to Thadzi etc.

name me a middleweight champ who won a heavyweight title who isnt an ATG

It'll always be a draw and a no contest on his record.

[Samuel F.]

Yep. Also, voted wrong so that should be 7-0.