Is Margarito Cotto's first big test?

[Live Dog]

What do the odds makers gotta do with anything? They're not the final say on who the general public & analysts thinks will win the fight. Before I started posting on here there were maaaad people saying Judah & Mosley were gonna beat Cotto. There were a lot of people going for Quintana too because he was supposedly the "stronger" Welterweight and was also undefeated.

Bottom line, ya'll are reaching trying to discredit Cotto's opponents...but chill, don't make fun of Margarito for losing to Williams and Santos and almost catching an L from then unknown Clottey. He's ****in dangerous son!!!!

nice try....son

[Xyei]

I think even a past it Shane is a better test than Margarito but we will see on fight night.

[Live Dog]

I think even a past it Shane is a better test than Margarito but we will see on fight night.

Ok, you're a reasonable poster, answer me this........Shane's WW career consists of one big win and one big won only, Oscar. How can this guy be considered that big of a test at WW?

[Boofdatruth]

Lovemore N'dou - lost to Junior witter. Enough said.

Corley - a gatekeeper almost KO'd Cotto

Torres - took the fight on short notice and almost put Cotto away

Branco - lost to Gatti. Enough said.

Malignaggi - 7-1 underdog going into the fight and has received two gift decisions in his last two fights. Also not known as anywhere near a big puncher, he had Cotto hurt.

Quintana - we all saw his last fight.

Urkal - lol

Judah - who hasn't beaten this guy

Mosley - was a great fighter, but his last big win was against Oscar in '03. A fight most thought he lost.

Gomez - that's right, Alfonso Gomez.

some of the descriptions are right on, and some are a bit convoluted. Good post. I feel that cotto has not been truly tested for being a champ for as long as he has been.

[Boofdatruth]

you sure are making it seem like cotto's resume is handpicked and weak. why would you do that?

His comp isn't weak, but it isn't strong. He has never been tested, and i believe that. For a fighter with that many defense, and how long he has been a champ, he has not been truly tested yet.

[Boofdatruth]

How was Mosley not a real Test? He's easily a top two or three welter.

Because he fought nothing like he did in his prime when he fought cotto.

[Xyei]

Ok, you're a reasonable poster, answer me this........Shane's WW career consists of one big win and one big won only, Oscar. How can this guy be considered that big of a test at WW?

That's a good point. I guess I was letting Shane's accomplishments at lower weight classes gloss over my opinion. I hadn't thought of it that way (the right way ) I guess.

I can admit when I'm wrong.

[Boofdatruth]

Is Live Dog Cotto's biggest hater? is the real question..

Why is it that when someone says anything about cotto, you guys get defensive, but let anything roll off your tongues the minute you can insult floyd mayweather? Live Dog is asking a legit question, and you guys are bypassing the question.

[Xplosivo]

That's a good point. I guess I was letting Shane's accomplishments at lower weight classes gloss over my opinion. I hadn't thought of it that way (the right way ) I guess.

I can admit when I'm wrong.

thats why most think your a good poster

[Boofdatruth]

No he hasn't.

How did they return with a question when a question was asked? lol