Who's higher on your ATG list, Mayweather or Whitaker?

[IMDAZED]

Whitaker has been retired for some time, Mayweather retired a few days back. just wait and see who history will be kinder too, just dont kill yourself when your sporty at 40 and mayweather is regarded as one of the ATG's

I won't. And I sincerely hope he is considered an ATG. I just hope you don't die when you realize that Whitaker is still ranked higher.

LOL@you, trying to hype up Ricky Hatton and put down AZUMAH NELSON. Someone should send you the knob slobber Award of the Year for that one.

[Live Dog]

Ring Magazine currently rates Pernell Whitaker the 9th greatest fighter of all time. Using your logic, he'll have climbed a few notches a few decades from now.

Which also goes to show you how ****ed up ESPN is as they rated Pea the 44th best fighter of all time!!??

Anyways, Whitaker was the better fighter of the two and the best fighter I've ever seen.

[IMDAZED]

Which also goes to show you how ****ed up ESPN is as they rated Pea the 44th best fighter of all time!!??

Anyways, Whitaker was the better fighter of the two and the best fighter I've ever seen.

It's ESPN, dog - what did you expect?

[Live Dog]

It's ESPN, dog - what did you expect?

I know, but 44!!??

[Silencers]

Whitaker definitely deserves to be higher than 44, great fighter.

[Xplosivo]

I won't. And I sincerely hope he is considered an ATG. I just hope you don't die when you realize that Whitaker is still ranked higher.

LOL@you, trying to hype up Ricky Hatton and put down AZUMAH NELSON. Someone should send you the knob slobber Award of the Year for that one.

you should get idiot of the year award for saying floyd hasnt won any linear titles. YES PEOPLE THIS IDIOT DID SAY THAT! LMFAO...READ! READ!

Anyway...

The guy's Nelson beat:

Wilfredo Gomez - Well past his prime, near retirement, best days at a lower weight class. (If you count Gomez for Nelson, then also count Kostya Zoo and Castillo for Hatton, or Genaro Hernandez beating Azumah Nelson)

Other names: Jeff Fenech & Jesse James Leija

Lol, but Mayweather "NEEDED NELSON TO BE GREAT"

your a laughing stock dude, seriously.

[IMDAZED]

I know, but 44!!??

I'd like to see this list. I'm scared. I bet Oscar's top 20, Roy is top 50 and they have Vitali Klitschko at #25.

[Live Dog]

I'd like to see this list. I'm scared. I bet Oscar's top 20, Roy is top 50 and they have Vitali Klitschko at #25.

Oscar is 39. Yes Oscar above Pea.

SRL is 12. Now if you want to argue that SRL is better than Pea then that's fine. But, to say that there is 27 places between the two is f'd up.

[IMDAZED]

Oscar is 39. Yes Oscar above Pea.

SRL is 12. Now if you want to argue that SRL is better than Pea then that's fine. But, to say that there is 27 places between the two is f'd up.

Oscar above Pea...?

Wow...damn, I knew it. ESPN is just the worst, man. Seriously. It's obvious a casual fan did that list. If you have a link to it, let me see.

No wonder these Johnny Come Lately's have so much heart. They checked out the ESPN list and go off on that. When they aren't looking at BOXREC.

[Live Dog]

http://boxing.about.com/od/history/a/50_greatest.htm