Joe himself only has had only three meaningful career wins. Lets not get that twisted with the padded Zolte Erdei-esque title defenses.
Jeff Lacy was unproven and not the real champ of his division like Pavlik. Pavlike defeated the real champ to get his title. Kessler also was just a title holder. Lets not try spin this. Were those two Top 10 P4P when Calzaghe fought them?
Pavlik has earned a shot at joe by being in the top 10 P4P and being the real champ of his division. And the notion that fighting Pavlik wouldn't prove anything is ludicrous. Lets not act like Calzaghe is this long time champion at the top of his throne and Kelly being a new comer.
None of his opposition was genuinely incredible, Kelly is just the best young fighter near Joe's weight class that America currently has. Lacy was in the same position, so too was the non-American Kessler, Joe beat both after plenty of people said about them what they say about Pavlik now. And they were in his weight class!
How anyone can talk of Joe "proving himself" against Pavlik is beyond me. If anything Pavlik needs to earn a shot at Joe, for which moving up to SMW would probably be a good start. Kelly right now, is in the same position Joe was years ago, and I repeat, the notion that fighting Pavlik would prove anything is ludicrous.
Comment