Does Quintana deserve/Do you want to see: The Rubber Match?

[Njord777]

Good post.

About Quintana being a bit too timid, while its possible, we'd have to wait and see. Williams looked so dejected after the first fight, and so discouraged that it at times was hard for me imagining him getting anything but stopped late, but he came in ****ing hungry! Its possible that Carlos comes too gun-shy, its also possible that he comes to kill.

I see the logic there, but he didn't look like a shark who smelled blood after getting spanked by Cotto. I mean, while Quintana didn't look like a shell of himself after the fight with Miguel, he's never come out the gates looking like an animal, either. You're right, we'll have to wait and see...but I think Cintron has more pride than Quintana, and will try and prove himself after his last performance. Of course, that's not based on anything but my random guessology.

[Slotff]

I see the logic there, but he didn't look like a shark who smelled blood after getting spanked by Cotto. I mean, while Quintana didn't look like a shell of himself after the fight with Miguel, he's never come out the gates looking like an animal, either. You're right, we'll have to wait and see...but I think Cintron has more pride than Quintana, and will try and prove himself after his last performance. Of course, that's not based on anything but my random guessology.

But its safe guessology, because you are right, Quintana has never really looked like a serial killer, and at best has been SURPRISING. While I think Quintana would stop Cintron, Cintron has looked SENSATIONAL before (i.e. Mathyesse)

[Njord777]

But its safe guessology, because you are right, Quintana has never really looked like a serial killer, and at best has been SURPRISING. While I think Quintana would stop Cintron, Cintron has looked SENSATIONAL before (i.e. Mathyesse)

The tune you sing in is the truth, sir. Ha.

[The_Italian]

Do you want to see it?

The 1st fight: Quintana clearly, and with a fair amount of ease outboxes Williams to take a good, clear UD.

The 2nd fight: Williams catches Quintana and Carlos never recovers. Williams wins by KO1.

Quintana was not dominated in the 2nd fight, just got caught and never recovered. I thought it was an either way fight, and didn't really have a pick, but the outcome suprised me. Quintana has the skill to keep it close, and beat, or lose closely to Williams if he doesn't get caught/keeps his hands up. Who wins the 3rd fight?

I think a 3rd fight is warranted...i mean in all honesty its only fair.

quintana beat him first...williams came back and won the second fight i think a 3rd fight would be the best solution to avoid all future disputes.

In a 3rd fight i see Williams decisioning quintana in a close SD or close UD.

Paul williams i believe has learned to stay on the outside and utilize his jab to keep quintana away (from what i seen in that short round and only round of the fight)...it williams were to continue with such gameplan he can win a decision in my opinion.

Had williams used the jab and stayed on the outside in the first fight he could have won it.

i think that was the deciding factor...he just fought small and quintana took full advantage.

Williams by Decision.