Does Quintana deserve/Do you want to see: The Rubber Match?

[Boofdatruth]

Quintana by Decision, the way I see it Williams will come overconfident just like the first fight and Quintana will outbox him once more, the thing is Williams is already overconfident, he called out the big names like if he could destroy them (he may defeat Margarito but I'm sure Cotto could outbox him or Knock him out with a clean left hook to the body). So Quintana by either Split Decision or Unanimous Decision.

Quintana has no chin. He may be done at the highest level.

[Vigilant3]

But Williams didn't have to prove himself after being dominated in the first fight?

Nice double-standards. A re-match clause doesn't have to take effect immediately and fighters are open to take a different fight inbetween. Quintana could have opted for this -- he didn't. Williams didn't look any more impressive than Quintana did in the first fight.

Like I've said before -- a single punch can change the flow. Paul caught him flush and he couldn't recover. That isn't telling of who is better when we've already seen dominance from the other side.

[shynequasiog22]

Of course he deserves a rematch because of how he dominated the first fight. I don't know if it was because of their contract but he gave Williams an immediate rematch and Paul should want to prove he didn't just catch him with a lucky shot. I pick Williams by decision because I think Quintana will be a lot more cautious if they fight again but won't do enough to get the W.

[THE REED]

Griffin-Jones I and II is not a valid comparison. Roy controlled the first fight and was on his way to knocking Griffin. Paul pretty much got dominated in his 1st fight.

THats why I said.... some think...

If you were to talk to those sum.... its quite comparable...

I myself wouldnt mind a III fight... but its not necessary.. as some say.

[Drunken Cat]

I voted Williams KO but I'd still like to see the fight.

[WLAD OWNS]

Williams is overrated....He was fortunate enough to catch an overconfident Quintana early and Quintana never recovered.

Quintana exposed Williams in the first fight and schooled him.

I think we would see a more determined Quintana in a trilogy and he would school Williams again.

[THE REED]

Williams is overrated....He was fortunate enough to catch an overconfident Quintana early and Quintana never recovered.

Quintana exposed Williams in the first fight and schooled him.

I think we would see a more determined Quintana in a trilogy and he would school Williams again.

If anything was exposed... It was Williams UNDERRATED power, and Quintanas OVERRATED ability to take it...

[ferocity]

Quintanna deserves a rematch. He earned it the first time out where he clearly beat Williams.

[Left2body]

People think montell griffin was winning the first fight... and what did roy do in the rematch?

CLEAR UP THE CONFUSION.

Same thing happened with Paul.

Nobody wanted a montell rubber match, and we dont need a Quintana rubber match.

When you beat someone by 4 points, then they knock you out in 2 minutes.


****, Ill take it though... line up the bets again...

Case Closed.

Dude that is a horrible comparison. Montel winning via DQ after he had already been dropped is not equivalent to Quintana clearly beating and outclassing PW's in his win.

Not to take anything away from PW but it was a very good shot that won him the fight. But it all came from that one shot which Quintana never recovered from. The round was pretty much even till that point.

[THE REED]

Dude that is a horrible comparison. Montel winning via DQ after he had already been dropped is not equivalent to Quintana clearly beating and outclassing PW's in his win.

Not to take anything away from PW but it was a very good shot that won him the fight. But it all came from that one shot which Quintana never recovered from. The round was pretty much even till that point.

Thats why I started my post off with

"PEOPLE THINK...."

Me not being one of them...