Manny Pacquiao or Joe Calzaghe: Who is The P4P Best?

[Mushashi]

Pacquiao by default.

[JunglistSoldja]

Manny Pacquiao

[Pullcounter]

In shocking fashion, Floyd Mayweather Jr, regarded as the best fighter in the sport, announced his retirement from boxing on Friday. The public debate will now begin as to who is the best pound-for-pound fighter in the sport. [details]

pacquiao is #1 now

[DanMan_UK]

Calzaghe Best P4p!

Calzaghe is p4p #1 now

As in a hypothetical fight were they are the same weight, Calzaghes boxing skills would engulf Paquiao and wear him down, and would probably knock him out!

[CloudJay]

pacman by default
if pacman and joe are in a same division, pac would destroy that slapper

[GTL]

PACMAN period..

LOOK at his resume..

To be the best you CHALLENGE the BEST..

JC NEVER did that until um, never..

[starjammer]

I have to say Pacquiao.

But somebody raised the excellent point there.... if the two fought each other, Calzaghe would win!

Isn't that what the P4P mythos was built around? Who would beat who?

Not who did what?

Correct me if I am wrong.

[VERDUGO]

it doesn't take a genius to figure this **** out.
PAC was listed #2 so he SHOULD be #1 now.

[-Antonio-]

I said Calzaghe until Pacquiao destroys Diaz, but now I take that back.

Manny has to be number one. He beat Marquez the first time imo, and he took out a still p4p rated Barrera too. Not to mention he has a handful of other good wins too ranging from Flyweight to Super Feather.

[PBF Mayweather]

Pac lost his last fight IMO so how the heck could it be him. Mayweather is going to come back anyways.