Had Judah beat Kostya, Spinks I & Mayweather (as well as Baldo)...

[El Chicano]

You don't have to ask the question, it's common sense over ******ity.

Hmmmm... if a fighter didn't lose and kept beating big names in important fights.... would he be the best? Does that really need to be answered? Does that honestly need explaining?

******. ****ing. Thread.

Thank You!!!

[Dorian]

Yes he would be P4P #1 right now

[COACH WEBB]

Yes he would be P4P #1 right now

Thanks Dorian, for the simple answer....

[Derranged]

i give judah props because even though he lost he at least tries to fight the best. the only man he ever ducked was margarito.

??????? When exactly did this happen?

[El Chicano]

yesterday.

[squealpiggy]

would he be the BEST fighter alive right now?

What the **** kind of question is this? If Tony Booth had beaten Bernard Hopkins, Nigel Benn, Chris Eubank, Joe Calzaghe, Roy Jones Junior, James Toney, Evander Holyfield, Mike Tyson and Lennox Lewis he'd be the best fighter alive. He didn't though.

****, if Sugar Ray Robinson had the Holy Grail from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade would he be the best fighter alive today?

Wow.

[COACH WEBB]

What the **** kind of question is this? If Tony Booth had beaten Bernard Hopkins, Nigel Benn, Chris Eubank, Joe Calzaghe, Roy Jones Junior, James Toney, Evander Holyfield, Mike Tyson and Lennox Lewis he'd be the best fighter alive. He didn't though.

****, if Sugar Ray Robinson had the Holy Grail from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade would he be the best fighter alive today?

Wow.

it is a yes or no question about JUDAH.

[juancho]

i meant yes but i put no,but you can pretty much do this with any fighter so wats the point?

[MANGLER]

Hell no, but at least he'd be more than a talented fighter who always blows the big fights.

[Bizzle_LDN]

The most ridiculous poll I've seen on this site to date.