Had Judah beat Kostya, Spinks I & Mayweather (as well as Baldo)...

[COACH WEBB]

i give judah props because even though he lost he at least tries to fight the best. the only man he ever ducked was margarito.

says the Margarito TROLL.....

[VIVA MEXICO!!]

says the Margarito TROLL.....

judah was supposed to fight margarito in april instead of the cintron fight. but when they were about to make the deal judah got out of his contract with his promoter to avoid the fight. educate yourself.

http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12203

[ReadyUp]

That's alot of mutha****in IF's!

[Sin City]

Yes, but he didn't.. wins over Mayweather, Kostya and Spinks are huge.
It would have been insane if he would have beaten Cotto too..

But back to reality.. he didn't, so why does it matter? It doesn't. Thread is pointless.

[COACH WEBB]

Yes, but he didn't.. wins over Mayweather, Kostya and Spinks are huge.
It would have been insane if he would have beaten Cotto too..

But back to reality.. he didn't, so why does it matter? It doesn't. Thread is pointless.

the thread is NOT pointless..it was a question....I just wanted to see where the board stood on it.... your post to this POINTLESS thread is what you call.....POINTLESS!

[El Chicano]

Get outta here, bit waster.

[Dirt E Gomez]

the thread is NOT pointless..it was a question....I just wanted to see where the board stood on it.... your post to this POINTLESS thread is what you call.....POINTLESS!

The point is how far and outlandish is. It's one thing to ask people to imagine changing 1 fight's decision around.... but 4? That's absurd. You might as well say...

There's a fictional boxer I created. He lived for a 150 years and finished his record at 450-0-0 (449ko's) and changed weight classes non-stop and fought every competitor at every weight he wanted to. His one fight that wasn't won by KO was when he won by DQ against Golota.

Was he the greatest fighter ever?!?!?!?!?!

I think so.

[Sin City]

the thread is NOT pointless..it was a question....I just wanted to see where the board stood on it.... your post to this POINTLESS thread is what you call.....POINTLESS!

If I would have been born with wings I could fly.. but I wasn't was I?
Again, pointless ass thread from a pointless ass poster.
Go play with your imaginary friend Jesus in traffic.. while your African brothers laugh at you and call you a "good nicca" for selling out your culture and religion.

[PoetryInMotion]

no, cotto still would be better.

[COACH WEBB]

The point is how far and outlandish is. It's one thing to ask people to imagine changing 1 fight's decision around.... but 4? That's absurd. You might as well say...

There's a fictional boxer I created. He lived for a 150 years and finished his record at 450-0-0 (449ko's) and changed weight classes non-stop and fought every competitor at every weight he wanted to. His one fight that wasn't won by KO was when he won by DQ against Golota.

Was he the greatest fighter ever?!?!?!?!?!

I think so.

The reason that I asked the question was because of HOW Judah failed in BIG fights. We all know that he has a WORLD of talent. I believe that in ALL of the fights that he lost, he DEF could have won. Therefore, had he won in those BIG fight, would he be the BEST fighter right now? How is that absurd and outlandish?