Who really won Gayweather vs Castillo 1?

[TCNŽ SOULJAH]

Ask Calzaghe if he gave Reid an immediate rematch, geez.

Let's see _Ricky_ weasel his way out of this one. Mayweather fought Castillo injured and still won. However, some raised doubts over the decision, so Floyd gave Castillo a rematch and won clearly. Calzaghe got a similarly debated decision win over Reid, took it and ran.

That says all about the difference between these two fighters. The efforts of _Ricky_ to discredit the Floyd Mayweather Jr. résumé as inferior to that of Joe Calzaghe, of all résumés, are just pitiful.

[daggum]

Personally, I think people make to big of deals when heads come together. I think Rabbit Punches and low blows (intentional, not Joe's) are much worse.

People said Campbell was a dirty fighter in the Diaz fight because they kept headbutting. If their heads come together and someone doesn't throw their head at another I think it shouldn't be made as big of a deal as people make it out to to be.

joe admitted in a post fight interview to intentionally hitting hopkins low cause he was mad he got knocked down.

[warp1432]

If you wathched the fight you would know that all of the announcers and Harold had it for Castillo.

I did and I saw Mayweather beating Castillo in a very close fight.

Harold ledderman also had Paul Williams over Carlos Quintana by the way.

[Clegg]

joe admitted in a post fight interview to intentionally hitting hopkins low cause he was mad he got knocked down.

No, someone here posted a thread claiming that, but it was later shown that the quote was fake.

You have 240 posts on this board, most of them slagging of either Calzaghe, Hatton, or British people in general. You even tried to turn a discussion on Kelly Pavlik into a criticism of Calzaghe fighting Salem.

[1pretty boy1]

floyd won the first fight this ****ing lederman was drunk that night,floyd won the first 5 rounds clearly and the round where castillo was deducted a point floyd won it too but this ****ing lederman scored it as a draw.it was a very close fight and great perfomance from castillo but he didn't win the fight 114-113 for floyd,don't forget floyd had an injury that night.

what he did to castillo in the 2 fight,it was amazing castillo looked like an idiot he couldn't do a **** my score was 118-110 for floyd and again this ***** lederman scored it close 115-113 for floyd and this because many bitches like you haters said that floyd lost the 1 fight and if floyd didn't win the 2 fight so impressivly the judges would give it to castillo as the "compensation'' for 1 fight,but he done it he dominated castillo along the whole fight.

[daggum]

No, someone here posted a thread claiming that, but it was later shown that the quote was fake.

You have 240 posts on this board, most of them slagging of either Calzaghe, Hatton, or British people in general. You even tried to turn a discussion on Kelly Pavlik into a criticism of Calzaghe fighting Salem.

i was properly warning people that pavlik might turn into calzaghe if he continues fighting industrial waste like gary lockett and mger mtchrkian. and we all do not want that.