Who really won Gayweather vs Castillo 1?

[RichCCFC]

Harold Lederman scored it 115-111 Castillo as did a lot of other boxing experts.

Compubox punchstats

Total Punches	Castillo	Mayweather
Landed	203	157
Thrown	506	448
Pct.	40%	35%
Power Punches	Castillo	Mayweather
Landed	173	66
Thrown	377	151
Pct.	46%	44%

[TonyJ]

Castillo won.

[Fox McCloud]

I don't score fights, but just to sabotage your ****** ****ing thread that has been made over 50 times (you could have just bumped an old one... douchebag), I voted Mayweather.

Keep beating the dead horse, while Calzaghe is beating your ass up with his sac.

[KnockoutTheFat]

DUHHH Joe Calzaghe won that fight.

[Chunk..]

_Ricky_ is on a mission!

[warp1432]

Mayweather did. And correction, a lot of people ringside had it spilt. No way did people score it 115-111 for Castillo. That was a joke score.

[Dorian]

I don't score fights, but just to sabotage your ****** ****ing thread that has been made over 50 times (you could have just bumped an old one... douchebag), I voted Mayweather.

Keep beating the dead horse, while Calzaghe is beating your ass up with his sac.

Dwiens > life

[Dirt E Gomez]

I don't score fights, but just to sabotage your ****** ****ing thread that has been made over 50 times (you could have just bumped an old one... douchebag), I voted Mayweather.

Keep beating the dead horse, while Calzaghe is beating your ass up with his sac.

Zing.

Seriously, this thread is worthless as it has been done numerous times when the board wasn't filled with people who probably haven't even seen the fight.

I love how everybody posts the punchstat numbers for that fight too... evidence right? Pffft, ******s.

[MANGLER]

I was one of the people who said Castillo won back when the 1st fight happened, not just since it has become the "in" thing to do hatin on Floyd the last year or so. But he got the decision and beat JLC clearly in the 2nd fight so it's a dead issue.

[Dynamite Kid]

close fight not the wide Castillo points win people like to think ,TBH its hard to make an assement when u have to listen to such biased commentry from Merchant etc

all i will say is Roger Mayweather was telling Floyd to go toe to toe with Castillo in the last round