Is Calzaghe a Top 25 Fighter in the last 30 Years?

[RJJp4pbaby]

is he ****. he'll be lucky to make the list for past ten years. He ducked everyone in their prime, why can nobody see this? Sven Ottke is a joke, and kessler is slightly above average and gave him big trouble. calslappy is a joke.

[hishaam15]

I think I would have an extremely difficult time coming up with 25 fighters that have sufficient achievements since the late 70s to surpass Calzaghe so yes, he is.

Calzaghe ws just a unified SMW champ... its easy to find 25 fighters who have acheived more, though they might not necessarily be better fighters.

[Dan...]

Calzaghe ws just a unified SMW champ... its easy to find 25 fighters who have acheived more, though they might not necessarily be better fighters.

I am talking in terms of resume and accomplishments when I talk about achievements.

Also, try not to place too much stock in people winning ****ty belts in 344 divisions, it is a mistake.

[DonFlamenco]

In the past 30 years there has just been too many greats for Joe to be able to crack top 25. I am sure one of these greats will beat him come Nov 8th.

[larryx]

here Are Some Fighters To Help You Decide...

Is Calzaghe Even Top 25 From The Last 30 Years?

Here Are Some Fighters...if You Think Calzaghe Comes In The Top 25, Who Is He Better Than From This List? Note These Are 37 Fighters, 12 More Than 25 For You To Chose...has Calzaghe Done More In His Career Than These:

1. Pernell Whitaker
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Felix Trinidad
4. Roy Jones Jr
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Marvin Hagler
7. Floyd Mayweather
8. Lennox Lewis
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Mike Tyson
11. Larry Holmes
12. George Foreman
13. Manny Pacquiao
14. Erik Morales
15. Marco Antonio Barrera
16. Julio Cesar Chavez
17. James Toney
18. Juan Manuel Marquez
19. Wilfredo Gomez
20. Alexis Arguello
21. miguel Cotto
22. Aaron Pryor
23. Roberto Duran
24. Kostya Tsyzu
25. Thomas Hearns
26. Sugar Ray Leonard
27. Winky Wright
28. Shane Mosley
29. Michael Spinks
30. jose Luis Castillo
31. Azumah Nelson
32. Alexis Arguello
33. Ricardo Lopez
34. diego Corrales
35. Mike Mccallum

If Yes Which Fighters Is He Better Than From This List? This Is Based On Accomplishments/achievements...

I Voted No But Then Again I Might Be Wrong..but Id Put Him Over Those Guys 4sho

[-Antonio-]

I dont know, the 80's alone produced about 20 fighters who would be seen as better.

[-Antonio-]

I Voted No But Then Again I Might Be Wrong..but Id Put Him Over Those Guys 4sho

Really? Over Pacman? No way...

[hishaam15]

I am talking in terms of resume and accomplishments when I talk about achievements.

Also, try not to place too much stock in people winning ****ty belts in 344 divisions, it is a mistake.

over the past decade i would call calzaghe one of the best, but this is 30 years were talking about!

so thats since 1978...

[them_apples]

in the end he beat Mikkel Kessler and Jeff Lacy

[them_apples]

I Voted No But Then Again I Might Be Wrong..but Id Put Him Over Those Guys 4sho

you can't be serious...maybe a bit over Corrales and Cotto..but the others? no. Just no.