who are A,B,C Class fighters in your opinion

[abadger]

Eubank & Benn never fought any fighters of the calibre of Mike McCallum

Maybe, maybe not. Not even each other?

[S.G.]

A Class:
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Israel Vasquez
Manny Pacquiao
Joe Calzaghe
i guess Kelly Pavlik until proven otherwise

B Class:
Bernard Hopkins
Rafael Marquez
Jermain Taylor
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Jorge Linares

C Class:
Edison Miranda
Arthur Abraham
Joshua Clottey
Samuel Peter
Kermit Cintron

[Dynamite Kid]

You DO know that Baldomir beat Gatti and Judah right?

yeah but we are talking a prime Gatti not a shot guy who has been in wars with Micky Ward ,Ivan Robinson ,Ruelas , he fought Gomez in his next fight for god sake and we all know how that went

Gatti was a better fighter for sure but i would not argue with Judah TBH i dont like him anyway LOL

[Live Dog]

A Class:
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Israel Vasquez
Manny Pacquiao
Joe Calzaghe
i guess Kelly Pavlik until proven otherwise

B Class:
Bernard Hopkins
Rafael Marquez
Jermain Taylor
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Jorge Linares

C Class:
Edison Miranda
Arthur Abraham
Joshua Clottey
Samuel Peter
Kermit Cintron

Wow. Vazquez is A, but Marquez is B? BHop is B?

[markosg]

A Class:
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Israel Vasquez
Manny Pacquiao
Joe Calzaghe
i guess Kelly Pavlik until proven otherwise

B Class:
Bernard Hopkins
Rafael Marquez
Jermain Taylor
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah
Jorge Linares

C Class:
Edison Miranda
Arthur Abraham
Joshua Clottey
Samuel Peter
Kermit Cintron

Thats pretty hash on Abraham considering he has never lost and Miranda given that his only loss was to an A Class!

[markosg]

Wow. Vazquez is A, but Marquez is B? BHop is B?

I know, I'm glad this guy never marked any of my University papers!!!!

[Jim Jeffries]

Thats pretty hash on Abraham considering he has never lost and Miranda given that his only loss was to an A Class!

Well if he ranks Abraham low, he has to rank Miranda low as welll, considering he lost to Abraham.

[Dynamite Kid]

Maybe, maybe not. Not even each other?

abadger Eubank & Benn are very good champions ,Good Fighters but Boxing is about Levels and neither of them are on the level of Mike McCallum

McCallum beat the **** out of Mike Watson a guy who beat Nigel Benn & gave Chris Eubank all he could handle he was also winning in his tragic 2nd bout with Eubank by a landslide

[TheGreatA]

Eubank & Benn never fought any fighters of the calibre of Mike McCallum

Maybe you should add + and - to get more out of it.

For example (based on the Ring Magazine p4p rankings):
Mayweather is A+
Calzaghe and Pacquiao are A
JM Marquez and Hopkins are A-
Vasquez, Cotto, Hatton and Pavlik are B+

[Zerwas1]

We should use ++ + - -- sometimes its hard to choose between two classes. Two seperated list for all time and current should be made, too.

Edit: Damn it, you beat to it by a few seconds