Does Floyd Deserve To Be Called Greater Than Sugar Ray?

[J_CON]

Robinson would destroy floyd

[DuttyAlacrity]

Shane Mosley is a B class fighter LMAO , but J L Castillo is Elite

I dont need to address your points about Ray Leonard he fought and beat 4 ATG ,arguably The best 160lbs fighter ever ,one of the best 147lbs fighters ever in Hearns ,probably the best LW ever in Duran ,Benitez

Floyd Best win is Oscar 34 years old ,lost 5 times ,notorious for gassing out in fights

Castillo was the elite AT lightweight... SSM claim to fame is his SD victory against ODLH WW and his BS UD of ODLH at SWW... he then lost to Vernon Forest and Winky Wright, respectively... the only elite fighter that he fought and beat is ODLH...
SRL won a controversial against arguably the best 160lbs fighter, refused to give him a rematch, HEARNS was at his best at SWW not WW and he was getting his ass handed to him before he caught Hearns with a good shot, he beat one of the best LW at WW (classes above his ideal class) so you did need to address my points... but you chose not to... like i said before i'm not saying PBF's better than SRL but it can be argued... the fact that you call pbf's win over ODLH his best win further lets me know that this convo is pointless...

[Dynamite Kid]

Castillo was the elite AT lightweight... SSM claim to fame is his SD victory against ODLH WW and his BS UD of ODLH at SWW... he then lost to Vernon Forest and Winky Wright, respectively... the only elite fighter that he fought and beat is ODLH...
SRL won a controversial against arguably the best 160lbs fighter, refused to give him a rematch, HEARNS was at his best at SWW not WW and he was getting his ass handed to him before he caught Hearns with a good shot, he beat one of the best LW at WW (classes above his ideal class) so you did need to address my points... but you chose not to... like i said before i'm not saying PBF's better than SRL but it can be argued... the fact that you call pbf's win over ODLH his best win further lets me know that this convo is pointless...

so Castillo was an Elite fighter but Shane was a b class fighter go play in the road Floyd boy ,Mosley would have destroyed Castillo at LW by KO possibly


Castillo good ,not great, not Elite IMO

[slicksouthpaw16]

Robinson beat every great fighter that was around his time and when the division was at its best. He was unbeaten at welterweight and has two wins over Kid Galivan, who is the second greatest welterweight of all time after Robinson. Let Mayweather beat Cotto, Margarito, Forrest, Mosley and Quintana then maybe we can even have a debate. Until then, lets not be ******ed. He only has 39 wins to Robinson's 173. Plus Ray fought all comers and didn't pick and choose. The only fighter that claims that Ray ducked him was Charely Burly, who used to live within 20 miles of me when he was still alive.

[robjr]

I picked no cuz LOL wasnt an option.

[KingTito]

No, and I don't know how anyone can make the argument.

[The Gambler1981]

Seriously, I do not rate Floyd above SRR but putting him on another planet from another great fighter is ludacris. If SRR is the perfect human fighting machine why do people even box anymore. I find it hard to believe perfection was reached 40 years ago and can never be touched again.

[SkillspayBills]

Floyd got a vote from a guy named "Mayweather4life", damn the huggers are out in full force.

[Williamb45]

Yes

Allucard, boxing_pundit85, Burner, cotto16, crazylegs7, Dorian, Flawless, HTownTexan, its_nothin24, jadagod, k1llu, mayweather4life, QUISQUEYA, Tmb04, withoutthee88

[FUC_U_PAYME]

No not when he ducks everybody in his weight class