Who do you feel should be ranked higher?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I think the same as El Rebelde De El Accordion. It shou be Clazaghe at # 2 but if Pac wins the Diaz fight he should be at #2 and if Floyd doesn't fight any top WW soon Pac should be #1 or Calzaghe depending of their next fights!

[Fox McCloud]

He could be replaced. However, to do it whoever was trying to take the #1 spot would have do a lot, not just in a fight or two of importance.

Barrera, Morales, Morales, Marquez isn't bad.

Eubank, Reid, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins isn't bad either.

I think the Kessler fight is one of the biggest wins that anyone can claim since quite a while ago. Who expected that fight to be so one-sided? And Kessler even looked great that night IMO.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Barrera, Morales, Morales, Marquez isn't bad.

Eubank, Reid, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins isn't bad either.

I think the Kessler fight is one of the biggest wins that anyone can claim since quite a while ago. Who expected that fight to be so one-sided? And Kessler even looked great that night IMO.

Quintana,Judah,Mosley,Margarito, Floyd Mayweather,won't be bad for Cotto either! Your forgetting if Cotto beats Margo and Floyd the P4P list will be very different!

[Burner]

thats a cop out burney. what you're practically saying is that Floyd no longer needs to beat top competition because he can beat them anyway so its ok for him to beat DECENT comp and should stay #1 regardless. that is crazy

I unlike MOST of b-scene...has followed Floyd Pre-Gatti.......

I seen his what he DID.....Which is why you dont see me in here saying he needs to fight Cotto...Clottey...Cintron...Williams.....Margarito ....Mosley....Quitana...Collazo and Berto.

He doesnt have to.

Margarito-Cotto winner OR Judah-Mosley winner....tops.

[Jim Jeffries]

Quintana,Judah,Mosley,Margarito, Floyd Mayweather,won't be bad for Cotto either! Your forgetting if Cotto beats Margo and Floyd the P4P list will be very different!

I wouldn't give Cotto credit for Margarito and Floyd just yet.

[Dirt E Gomez]

Barrera, Morales, Morales, Marquez isn't bad.

Eubank, Reid, Lacy, Kessler, Hopkins isn't bad either.

I think the Kessler fight is one of the biggest wins that anyone can claim since quite a while ago. Who expected that fight to be so one-sided? And Kessler even looked great that night IMO.

The manner in which you win means a lot. At least imo it does.

[Fox McCloud]

Quintana,Judah,Mosley,Margarito, Floyd Mayweather,won't be bad for Cotto either! Your forgetting if Cotto beats Margo and Floyd the P4P list will be very different!

Fair enough, but my thread is a question dealing with the present only.

Mayweather-Cotto isn't even on the horizon right now.

[2501]

I unlike MOST of b-scene...has followed Floyd Pre-Gatti.......

I seen his what he DID.....Which is why you dont see me in here saying he needs to fight Cotto...Clottey...Cintron...Williams.....Margarito ....Mosley....Quitana...Collazo and Berto.

He doesnt have to.

Margarito-Cotto winner OR Judah-Mosley winner....tops.

so then you're saying that he should stay @ #1 because of what he did PRE WW, almost 5 years ago? that even makes LESS sense!!!!!!11111111111

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I wouldn't give Cotto credit for Margarito and Floyd just yet.

I'm not creditng him for wins yet. I only said "IF" he beats both guys. Because anything can happend in boxing!

[Fox McCloud]

The manner in which you win means a lot. At least imo it does.

Same here, which is why I have Mayweather ahead of Pacquiao for the moment. All those wins were close except for against the guys who just didn't have it anymore, and Barrera I. Barrera I was his shining moment.

Calzaghe looked pretty good against Hopkins in my personal opinion. Just because his punches didn't hurt Hopkins doesn't mean **** to me. The Kessler win is mind-blowing to me. Oh yeah, and he did pretty okay against Lacy who was highly regarded at that point.